O dwu sposobach pozyskiwania organów do transplantacji

• Authors: Hołub Grzegorz

Title variants

EN

On Two Manners of Acquiring Organs for Transplantation

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

PL

Wprowadzenie; 1. W poszukiwaniu organów – współczesne propozycje rozwiązania problemu; 2. Czarny rynek organów – jego realia i konsekwencje; 3. Ku uregulowanemu rynkowi organów; 4. Antropologia wolnego rynku organów; 5. W stronę alternatywnego myślenia o osobie i jej cielesności; 6. Poszukiwanie organów do transplantacji: logika daru; Zakończenie.

EN

The technical possibility of carrying out transplantations of different human organs is usually associated with their scarce availability. Two solutions are put forward in order to deal with the issue: acquiring organs via a free market or sensitizing people to donation of organs as gifts. In the article these two proposals are considered with a special emphasis on the philosophical concepts of the person and his/her body which are presupposed in them. Critical examination reveals that a human body is an integral part of the person, hence cannot be treated as a commodity. Bodily organs can be treated, however, as a gift of one person to another. The logic of gift, then, is more adequate to who the person is, and it should influence people’s attitudes concerning organ donation.

• Publisher: Gdańskie Seminarium Duchowne
• Journal: Studia Gdańskie
• Year: 2009
• Issue: 25
• Pages: 129-146

Contributors

author

Hołub Grzegorz

• Wydział Filozoficzny Uniwersytet Papieski Jana Pawła II Kraków

References

• Andrews, L. B. 2000. My Body, My Property. W: Life Choices. A Hasting Center Introduction to Bioethics, red. J. H. Howell, W. F. Sale, 463‒483. Washington D.C.
• Biesaga, T. 2006. Wobec zgody domniemanej i zawłaszczania zwłok do transplantacji Medycyna Praktyczna 1, 20‒24.
• Blumstein, J. F. 1992. The Case for Commerce ‘in Organ Transplantation’. Transplantation Proceedings t. 24, nr 5, 2191‒2197.
• Cherry, M. 2005. Kidney for Sale by Owner. Human Organs, Transplantation, and Market. Washington D.C.
• Cohen, E. 2006. Biotechnology and the Spirit of Capitalism. The New Atlantis, Spring, 9‒23.
• Descartes, R. 2002. Rozprawa o metodzie. Tłum. T. Żeleński-Boy. Kęty.
• Dworkin, G. 1994. Markets and Morals: The Case for Organ Sales. W: Morality, Harm and the Law, red. G. Dworkin, 145‒157. Boulder.
• Gneezy, U., Rustichini, U. 2000. A Fine Is a Price. Journal of Legal Studies 29, 1‒17.
• Heyd, D. 2006. Supererogation. W: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, http://plato. stanford.edu/entries/supererogation.
• Higgins, R., i in. 2003. Kidney Transplantation in Patients Travelling from the UK to India or Pakistan. Nephrol Dial Transplant t. 18, nr 4, 851‒852.
• Hippen, B. 2006. The Case for Kidney Markets. The New Atlantis, Fall, 47‒61.
• Hughes, P. M. 2006. Ambivalence, Autonomy, and Organ Sales. The Southern Journal of Philosophy t. XLIV, 237‒251.
• Kluge, E.-H. W. 1999. Organ Donation and Retrieval: Whose Body Is It anyway? W: Bioethics. An Anthology, red. H. Kuhse, P. Singer, 387‒389. Oxford.
• Lecaldano, E. 2002. Donazione di organi. W: Dizionario di bioetca, red. E. Lecaldano, Bari, 100‒102.
• Locke, J. 1955. Rozważania dotyczące rozumu ludzkiego. Tłum. B. J. Gawęcki. Warszawa.
• Meilaender, G. 2006. Gifts of the Body. The New Atlantis, Summer, 25‒35.
• Meyer, S. 2006. Trafficking in Human Organs in Europe. A Myth or an Actual Threat? European Journal of Crime, Criminal Law and Criminal Justice t. 14, nr 2, 208‒229.
• Rada Europy. 2003. Trafficking in Organs in Europe. Committee on Legal Affairs and Human Rights, http://www.transplantation-information.de/organhandel/handel_ mit_organen_informationen/trafficking_in_organs_in_europe_doc9845.pdf, z dn. 12 grudnia 2009 r.
• Rai, M. A., Afzal, O. 2007. Organs in the Bazaar. The End of the Beginning? Politics and the Life Sciences t. 25, nr 1, May, 10‒11.
• Rivera-Lopez, E. 2006. Organ Sales and Moral Distress. Journal of Applied Philosophy t. 23, nr 1, 41‒52.
• Rothman, S. M., Rothman, D. J. 2006. The Hidden Cost of Organ Sale. American Journal of Transplantation 6, 1524‒1528.
• Scheper-Hughes, N. 2003a. Organ without Borders. Foreign Policy, January/February, 26‒27.
• Scheper-Hughes, N. 2003b. Rotten Trade: Millennial Capitalism, Human Values and Global Justice in Organ Trafficking. Journal of Human Rights t. 2, nr 2, 197‒226.
• Shearmur, J. 2008. The Real Body Shop, Part 2: Spare Parts. Policy t. 24, nr 1, 25‒32.
• Surman, O. S., i in. 2008. The Market of Human Organs: A Window into a Poorly Understood Global Business. Transplantation Proceedings 40, 491‒493.
• Światowa Organizacja Zdrowia. 2004. Organ Trafficking and Transplantation Pose New Challenges. Bulletin of the World Health Organization t. 82, nr 9, 715.
• Taylor, J. S. 2002. Autonomy, Constraining Options, and Organ Sales. Journal of Applied Philosophy t. 19, nr 3, 273‒285.
• Titmuss, R. M. 1971. The Gift Relationship: From Human Blood to Social Policy. New York.
• Waltz, E. 2006. The Body Snatchers. Nature Medicine t. 12, nr 5, 487‒488.
• Wojtyła, K. 1986.Miłość i odpowiedzialność. Lublin.
• Wojtyła, K. 1994. Osoba i czyn. W: Osoba i czyn i inne pisma antropologiczne, red. zbior. 43‒344. Lublin.
• Wójcik, B. 2005. Ksenotransplantacje. W: Encyklopedia bioetyki, red. A. Muszala, 252‒255. Radom.
• Veatch, R. M. 2000. Transplantation Ethics. Washington D.C.
• Zutlevics, T. L. 2001. Markets and the Needy: Organ Sales or Aid? Journal of Applied Philosophy t. 18, nr 3, 297‒302.