Seaside Communities in Crisis: On the Construction of Collective Identity in a Japanese Whaling Town after the Moratorium

• Authors: Sowa Frank
• Languages of publication: EN

Abstracts

EN

After the whaling moratorium of the International Whaling Commission (IWC) came into force in 1986, Japanese whaling activities such as small−type coastal whaling, scientific whaling in the Antarctic, driving whaling or hand−harpooning continued on a reduced level. The zero−catch moratorium had an enormous impact on the whalers’, the whalers families and the traditional whaling towns. Being located in very remote rural areas, seaside communities found themselves involved in crisis concerning their economic, cultural, spiritual, social and moral development. Results of ethnographic fieldwork conducted in a contemporary whaling town in Japan show that whaling is still a part of the collective memory of the town: whalers and non−whalers construct their identities through the articulation of a strong attachment to the traditional whaling town and their ancestors. From the very beginning whaling was an economic activity, an industry, but it was so dominant (“whales are my life”) that all inhabitants were also involved in whaling related activities (sharing, arts and crafts). Today, whaling activities on the sea and on the land are decreasing. Additionally, whale and whaling symbolization is increasing. Inhabitants of the community experienced pressure from anti−whaling campaigns by global environmental groups and animal welfare organizations. Due to these experiences a new community identity emerged involving whaling as a reflected articulation, a marker of a cultural boundary in relation to Euro−Americans, but also in relation to urban Japanese and other rural communities which are not whaling, securing the future of the town as whaling town.

Keywords

EN

seaside community,; whaling,; moratorium,; collective identity,; resilience

• Publisher: Komisja Socjologii Morskiej - Filia Oddziału Gdańskiego w Szczecinie Polskiej Akademii Nauk
• Journal: Roczniki Socjologii Morskiej
• Year: 2014
• Volume: 23
• Pages: 21-35

Dates

published

2014

Contributors

author

Sowa Frank

• Institute for Employment Research, Nuremberg

References

• Akimichi, T. et. al. (1988), Small−Type Coastal Whaling in Japan. Report of an International Workshop. Occasional Publication No. 27. Edmonton: Boreal Institute for Northern Studies, Japan Social Sciences Association of Canada.
• Andresen, S. (1989), "Science and politics in the international management of whales", Marine Policy, 13(2):99−117.
• Aune, I. A., Praschma N. (1996), Greenpeace: Umweltschutz ohne Gewähr. Melsungen: Neumann−Neudamm Ed. Aktuell.
• Barth, F. (1998 [1969]), Ethnic groups and boundaries: the social organization of culture difference. Prospect Heights, IL: Waveland Press.
• Barthelmeß, K.(1992), "Auf Walfang − Geschichte einer Ausbeutung", in: Weidlich K. (ed.), Von Walen und Menschen. Hamburg: Historika−Photoverlag.
• Beatty, J., Takahashi J. (no date), A Guide to the Taiji Whale Museum and Whaling Sites in Taiji. Taiji: Taiji Whale Museum.
• Birnie, P. (1983), "34th meeting of the international whaling commission: Brighton, UK, 19−24 July 1982", Marine Policy, 7(1):64−68.
• Böttger, C. (2000), "Politik der Visualisation. Oder: Greenpeace macht Bilder, Bilder machen Greenpeace", in: Krüger Ch., Müller−Hennig M., Greenpeace auf dem Wahrnehmungsmarkt. Studien zur Kommunikationspolitik und Medienresonanz, Hamburg: Lit.
• Brown, M., May J. (1989), The Greenpeace Story. London: Dorling Kindersley.
• Cohen, A. P. (1985), The symbolic construction of community. London: Routledge.
• D'Amato, A., Chopra S. K. (1991), "Whales: Their Emerging Right to Life", The American Journal of International Law, 85(1):21−62.
• Donovan, G. P. (1982), Aboriginal/Subsistence Whaling (with special reference to the Alaska and Greenland Fisheries). Reports of the International Whaling Commission. Special Issue 4. Cambridge: International Whaling Commission.
• Einarsson, N. (1993), "All animals are equal but some are cetaceans. Conservation and culture conflict", in: Milton K., Environmentalism: The view from anthropology, London; New York: Routledge.
• Ellis, R. (1991), Men and Whales. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
• Freeman, M. R. (1990), "A Commentary on Political Issues with Regard to Contemporary Whaling", North Atlantic Studies, 2(1−2):106−16.
• Freeman, M. R., Kreuter U. P. (1994), Introduction. Basel: Gordon & Breach.
• Gambell, R. (1977), "Whale conservation: Role of the International Whaling Commission", Marine Policy, 1(4):301−10.
• — (1993), "International management of whales and whaling: an historical review of the regulation of commercial and aboriginal subsistence whaling", Arctic. 46(2):97−107.
• — (1997), "Recent developments in the IWC aboriginal subsistence whaling category", in: Pétursdóttir G., Whaling in the North Atlantic: Economic and political perspectives, Fisheries Research Institute.
• Greenland, F. (2013), "Towards a Modern Context for the Traditional Whaling Songs of Japan", Asia Pacific Perspectives, 11(1):52−73.
• Hunter, R., Weyler R. (1978), To save a whale: the voyages of Greenpeace. San Francisco: Chronicle Books.
• International Whaling Commission (1946), "International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling, Washington, 2nd December, 1946"
• Japan Small−Type Whaling Association (1998), A Decade of Disappointment (IWC/50/OS JSTWA). Tokyo: Japan Small−Type Whaling Association.
• — (1999), Japan's Twelve−year Battle for Coastal Minke Whaling: Twelve Years of Frustration (IWC/51/OS JSTWA). Tokyo: Japan Small−Type Whaling Association.
• — (2000), Cultural Significance and Needs of Japan's Small−type Coastal Whaling (IWC/52/OS JSTWA). Tokyo: Japan Small−Type Whaling Association.
• — (2001), Hypocrisy, Not Responsibility! (IWC/53/OS JSTWA). Tokyo: Japan Small−Type Whaling Association.
• — (2002), Japanese Community−Based Minke Whaling (IWC/54/OS JSTWA). Tokyo: Japan Small−Type Whaling Association.
• Kalland, A. (1993), "Management by Totemization: Whale Symbolism and the Anti−Whaling Campaign", Arctic, 46(2):124−33.
• — (1994), Whose Whale is That? Diverting the Commodity Path. Basel: Gordon & Breach.
• Kalland, A., Moeran B. (1992), Japanese Whaling: End of an Era? London: Curzon Press.
• Kock, K−H.(2002), "Wale – Sanfte Riesen oder Ratten der Meere? Ein Bericht über die Jahrestagung der Internationalen Walfangkommission", ForschungsReport Verbraucherschutz – Ernährung – Landwirtschaft, 2: 8−11.
• Komatsu, M., Misaki S. (2003), Whales and the Japanese. How we have come to live in harmony with the bounty of the sea. Tokyo: The Institute of Cetacean Research.
• — (2004), The History and Science of Whales. Tokyo: The Japan Times.
• Lynge, F. (1990), "Whaling: Samples from a Contemporary Debate", North Atlantic Studies, 2(1−2):138−44.
• Meyer, J. W. (1987), "The World Polity and the Authority of the Nation State", in: G. M. Thomas (ed.), Institutional structure: constituting state, society, and the individual. Newbury Park, London: Sage.
• Nicol, C. W. (1979), Taiji − Winds of Change: Japan Whaling Association.
• Oreskov, C., Sejersen F. (1993), "Arctic: The attack on Inuit whale hunting by animal rights groups", IWGIA−Newsletter, 3:10−16.
• Pálsson, G. (2006), "Nature and Society in the Age of Postmodernity", in: A. Biersack, J. B. Greenberg (eds.), Reimagining political ecology, Durham: Duke University Press.
• Peterson, J. H. (1993), "Epilogue: Whales and Elephants as Cultural Symbols", Arctic, 46(2):172−174.
• Promberger, M., Meier, L., Sowa, F., Boost, M. (2014), "Chancen des Resilienzbegriff s für eine soziologische Armutsforschung", in: M. Endreß, A. Maurer (eds.), Resilienz im Sozialen. Theoretische und empirische Analysen. Wiesbaden: Springer VS.
• Przyborski, A., Wohlrab−Sahr M. (2009), Qualitative Sozialforschung. Ein Arbeitsbuch. München: Oldenbourg.
• Ris, M. (1993), "Conflicting Cultural Values: Whale Tourism in Northern Norway", Arctic, 46(2):156−163.
• Rosenthal, Gabriele (2011), Interpretative Sozialforschung. Eine Einführung. Weinheim und München: Juventa Verlag.
• Roth, H. P., O'Barry R. (2010), Die Bucht: Flippers grausames Erbe. Bielefeld: Delius Klasing.
• Sakurai, H. (2010), The Last Harpooner: The End of Old Whaling, and an Introduction of American and Norwegian Whaling. Taiji: Taiji Whale Museum.
• — (2011), Whale Boats: Styles and Design. Taiji: Taiji Whale Museum.
• Segi, S.(2003), "The coexistence of whaling and whale watching in a traditional whaling region: The case of Taiji, Wakayama Prefecture, Japan." SPC Traditional Marine Resource Management and Knowledge Information Bulletin 15(July 2003):21−25.
• Sowa, F. (2013a), "Die Konstruktion von Indigenität am Beispiel des Internationalen Walfanges: Grönländische und japanische Walfänger im Streben nach Anerkennung", Anthropos. Internationale Zeitschrift für Völker− und Sprachenkunde, 108(2):445−462.
• — (2013b), "Indigenous Peoples and the Institutionalization of the Convention on Biological Diversity in Greenland", Arctic Anthropology, 50(1):72−88.
• — (2013c), "Relations of Power & Domination in a World Polity: The Politics of Indigeneity & National Identity in Greenland", in: Heininen L., Arctic Yearbook 2013. The Arctic of regions vs. the globalized Arctic. Akureyri: Northern Research Forum.
• — (2013d), "Taiji: Eine japanische Walfangstadt nach dem Moratorium." Fluke. Magazin für Wal−Motivsammler, 25 (2): 50−53.
• — (2013e), "„Was bedeutet ein Wal für Sie?“ – Divergenzen von Walperzeptionen in Deutschland, Japan und Grönland", Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung / Forum: Qualitative Social Research 14(1):Art. 10.
• — (2014), Indigene Völker in der Weltgesellschaft. Die kulturelle Identität der grönländischen Inuit im Spannungsfeld von Natur und Kultur. Bielefeld: transcript.
• Statistics Bureau Japan (2010), Population and Households, http://www.stat.go.jp.
• The Beneficiaries of the Riches of the Sea, and Japan Small−Type Whaling Association (1993), Small−type Coastal Whaling in Japan. Development of Japanese Whaling: Origins of LTCW, STCW and Pelagic Whaling. Tokyo: The Beneficiaries of the Riches of the Sea and Japan Small−Type Whaling Association.
• The Government of Japan (1997), Papers on Japanese Small−type Coastal Whaling. Submitted by the Government of Japan to the International Whaling Commission 1986−1996.

Identifiers

ISSN

0860−6552