Kulturowa przemoc ze względu na płeć. Przypadek zabójstw na tle honoru

• Authors: Agnieszka Gutkowska

Title variants

EN

Culture specific gender-based violence. Cases of honour killings

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

EN

Crimes related to the offender's cultural background are exceptional, and require special attention in many ways. Firstly, they come as far more shocking than the “typical” offences in a given society, due to their peculiar and infrequent nature. Secondly, as they are so much specific, they pose a serious challenge for law enforcement bodies, and it may seem that they are a significant problem for courts, who must face foreign and often culturally obscure situations and behaviour. This is also an important challenge for researchers, who try their best to define and, most of all, understand the mechanisms leading to such type of crime. The article discusses the specificity of honour killing, characterises the perpetrators and victims, and clarifies the motivational process of perpetrators, who often find themselves entangled in obligations enforced by cultural norms in a degree comparable to what their victims experience. The paper is also an attempt at analysis of the thesis widely found in the literature claiming that abuse towards women (irrespective of their cultural background and creed) stems from the patriarchal social structure, and should not be associated with any particular cultural system . The article claims that in order to properly analyse honour killing cases and create a possibly most effective system of preventing and countering the phenomenon, the expressions and sources of violence against women in different cultures must be precisely and unequivocally defined, and so must be the perpetrators' motivation. This clear division is necessary at the terminological level, to start with. This is why the article introduces the notion of “culture specific gender based violence”. Gender based violence itself is too broad a term to define such polarised cases as economic abuse of a wife by a husband, battering, or even marital rape and honour killing. Classifying honour killings as gender-based violence only, without precise identification of the sources behind such violence, is a dangerous practice, as - in consequence - opinions emerge equalising infringement of women's rights in the western world with those experienced in honour-based cultures or Muslim societies . The claim that women suffer the same violence regardless of culture or creed is not true. There is a dramatic difference between Christian background cultures, which nurture basic human rights, and honour cultures or Muslim communities, in the manner they treat women, and in the extent of socially accepted repression if they infringe the norms. What is even more, without changing the cultural rules or interpretation of religious rules, the position of women who are facing honour killings cannot improve. This is due to the fact that it is the culture and religion, or to be more precise, some elements of those, or instrumental use of those, that are at the source of this type of violence.

Keywords

PL

przemoc wobec kobiet; przestępstwa kulturowe; zabójstwa honorowe; culture violence; honour killings; przemoc wobec kobiet; przestępstwa kulturowe; zabójstwa honorowe; culture violence; honour killings

EN

culture violence; honour killings

• Publisher: Instytut Nauk Prawnych PAN / Institute of Legal Studies PAN
• Journal: Archiwum Kryminologii
• Year: 2013
• Issue: XXXV
• Pages: 137-160

Dates

published

2013-01-01

Contributors

author

Agnieszka Gutkowska

References

• J. Payton, Collective Crimes, Collective Victims. A Case Study of the Murder of Banaz Mahmod, w: M. Mazher Idriss, T. Abbas (red.), Honour, Violence, Women and Islam, New York 2011
• M. Płatek, Zabójstwa na tle honoru. Problem wyznania czy dyskryminacji ze względu na płeć, w: R. Wieruszewski, M. Wyrzykowski, L. Kondratiewa-Bryzik (red.), Prawne granice wolności sumienia i wyznania, Warszawa 2012
• P. Chesler, N. Bloom, Hindu v. Muslim Honor Killings, „Middle East Quarterly”, Summer 2012
• P. Chesler, Worldwide Trends in Honor Killings, „Middle East Quarterly”, Spring 2010, tom XVII, nr 2
• V. Meetoo, H.S. Mirza, There Is Nothing ‘Honourable’ about Honour Killings. Gender, Violence and the Limits of Multiculturalism, w: M. Mazher Idriss, T. Abbas (red.), Honour, Violence, Women and Islam, New York 2011
• R. Reddy, Gender, Culure and the Law: Approaches to ‘Honour Crimes’ in the UK, „Feminist Legal Studies” 2008, nr 16
• J.Q. Witman, Honor, w: D.S. Clark (red.), Encyclopedia of Law and Society. American and Global Perspectives, Los Angeles-London-New Delhi-Singapore 2007
• W. Boziewicz, Polski kodeks honorowy, Wrocław 1990
• H. Ijzermann, D. Cohen, Grounding Cultural Syndromes: Body Comportment and Values of Honor and Dignity Cultures, „European Journal of Social Psychology” 2011, nr 41
• Y. Feldner, „Honor” Murders – Why the Perps Get Off Easy, „Middle East Quarterly”, December 2000, tom VII, nr 4
• R. Doĝan, Is Honor Killing a „Muslim Phenomenon”? Textual Interpretations and Cultural Representations, „Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs”, September 2011, tom 31, nr 3
• P Chesler, Are Honor Killing Simply Domestic Violence?, „Middle East Quarterly”, Spring 2009, tom XVI, nr 2
• C. Stillwell, Honor Killings: When the Ancient and the Modern Collide. Tekst dostępny na stronie: www.meforum.org/2468/honor-killings-ancient-modern-collide
• A. Onal, Honor albo śmierć. Niewierne będą ginąć, Warszawa 2009.
• F. Faqir, Intrafamily Femicide in Defence of Honour: The Case of Jordan, „Third World Quarterly” 2001, tom 22, nr 1
• A. Gill, Reconfiguring ‘Honour’-Based Violence As a Form of Gendered Violence, w: M. Mazher Idriss, T. Abbas (red.), Honour, Violence, Women and Islam, New York 2011
• A. Chrzanowska, Tożsamość kulturowa uchodźców czeczeńskich, w: A. Gutkowska (red.), Uchodźcy w Polsce. Kulturowo-prawne bariery w procesie adaptacji, Warszawa 2007
• I. Adajew- Adger, Kamienie mówią. Dzieje i kultura Czeczenów, Warszawa 2005
• A. Gutkowska, M. Fajst, Globalizacja a przestępczość Polaków za granicą i cudzoziemców w Polsce, w: T. Giaro (red.), Prawo w dobie globalizacji, Warszawa 2011
• S. Cihangir, Gender Specific Honor Codes and Cultural Change, „Group Processes&Intergroup Relations” 2012, nr 16(3)
• P. Rodriguez, The Role of Concerns in Emotional Reactions to Offences, „Cognition&Emotion” 2002, nr 16(1)
• P. Rodriguez, A.S.R. Manstead, A.H. Fischer, The Role of Honor-Related Values in the Elicitation, Experience and Communication of Pride, Shame and Anger: Spain and the Netherlands Compared, „Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin” 2000, tom 26
• K. Helkama et al., Honor as a alue in Finland, Estonia, Italy, Russia and Switzerland, „Group Process&Intergroup Relations” 2013, nr 16(3)
• A. Kortweg, G. Yurdakul, Islam, Gender and Immigrant Integration: Boundary Drawing in Discourses on Honour Killing in the Netherlands and Germany, „Ethnic and Racial Studies”, February 2009, tom 32, nr 2
• P. Chesler, Are Honor Killing Simply Domestic Violence?, „Middle East Quarterly”, Spring 2009, tom XVI, nr 2
• P. Chesler, How Afgan Captivity Shaped My Feminism, „Middle East Quarterly”, Winter 2006
• N. Muhammad, M.M. Ahmed, Abdullah, F. Omer, N.H. Shah, Honor Killing in Pakistan: An Islamic Perspective, „Asian Social Science”, August 2012, tom 8, nr 10
• J. Van Broeck, Cultural Defence and Culturally Motivated Crimes (Cultural Offences), „European Journal of Crime, Criminal Law. & Criminal Justice” 2001, nr 9
• A. Phillips, When Culture Means Gender: Issues of Cultural Defence in English Courts, „Modern Law Review” 2003, nr 6
• A.D. Renteln, The Use and Abuse of the Cultural Defense, „Canadian Journal of Law and Society” 2005, tom 20, nr 1
• M. Tunick, Can Culture Excuse Crime? Evaluating the Inability Thesis, „Punishment Society” 2004, nr 6
• S. Sykuna, J. Zajadło, Kontrowersje wokół tzw. obrony przez kulturę – okoliczność wyłączająca winę, okoliczność łagodząca czy nadużycie prawa do obrony?, „Przegląd Sądowy” 2007, nr 6
• J. Zajadło, Uniwersalizm praw człowieka w konstytucji – bezpieczne i niebezpieczne relatywizacje, „Przegląd Sejmowy” 2007, nr 4
• O. Sitarz, Culture defence a polskie prawo karne, „Archiwum Kryminologii” 2007-2008, tom XXIX-XXX
• S. Maier, Protecting the Rights of German Muslim Women? Multiculturalism, ‘Honour’ Killings and the Cultural Defense in Germany, na stronie: www.citation.allacademic.com/meta/p_mla_ apa_research_citation/3/1/3/1/8/pages313189/p313189-1.php
• Ch. Taylor, The Politics of Recognition, w: A. Gutmann (red.), Multiculturalism. Examining the Politics of Recognition, New Jersey 1994
• A. Lipowska-Teutsch, Wychować, wyleczyć, wyzwolić, Warszawa 1998

Identifiers

DOI

10.7420/AK2013E