Requirement of Reference and the Problem of the Nature of Metaphysical Discourse

• Authors: Sebastian T. Kołodziejczyk

Title variants

PL

Postulat referencji w perspektywie pytania o naturę dyskursu metafizycznego

EN

Requirement of Reference and the Problem of the Nature of Metaphysical Discourse

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

PL

The crisis of metaphysics has many roots. One of them is recognized to be a kind of semantic failure. It lies in the fact that the meaning and reference of metaphysical propositions as well as metaphysical terms seems to be problematic. This diagnosis was first established by I. Kant and then repeated by some of the XXth century philosophers. In this paper I will show what role is played by what I called the Requirement of Reference (RR) in the analysis of the metaphysical discourse. I will argue that the RR draws the limitations for the conceptual and propositional schemata of metaphysics and, at the same time, prevents metaphysics from making de re assertions and utterances. I shall also examine in this light some of Ludwig Wittgenstein's theses from Tractatus and Philosophical Investigations in order to argue that two sorts of metaphysical considerations are possible despite of the above-mentioned criticism. One of them is the analysis of what might be shown but cannot be expressed in language. The other is the deep analysis of the conceptual schemata that constitute the foundations of human thought.

• Publisher: Uniwersytet Warszawski. Wydział Filozofii
• Journal: Filozofia Nauki
• Year: 2008
• Volume: 16
• Issue: 3-4
• Pages: 55-76

Dates

published

2008-09-01

Contributors

author

Sebastian T. Kołodziejczyk