Historia mówiona i źródła etnograficzne jako „wiedza pewna”. Przypadek potransformacyjnej historii Torgutów w zachodniej Mongolii oraz historii wsi Broniów w centralnej Polsce

• Authors: Rakowski Tomasz

Title variants

EN

Oral history and ethnographical sources as ‘certain knowledge’: the case of post-transformation history of the Torghut in western Mongolia and the history of the village of Broniów in central Poland

• Languages of publication: PL

Abstracts

In this article I focus on some methodological issues concerning knowledge production based on oral and informal sources while working in the field of the newest or immediate history. I show that still the oral sources are often treated as not fully valid while building historic knowledge and the reference to the written documents is conceived as much more stable and reliable. I refer to my field study among Torghuts from Western Mongolia in which I analyze local forms land-use and the practice of temporary possession and then I try to show that informal affairs and informal, oral data are much more important for understanding the latest history of a local town, Bulgan, and its spatial development. I also write about the case of Broniów village in central Poland, in which the informal practices of building houses, production of self-made bricks and so on, gives a very different sense of the history of Polish villages in recent decades. In this two case studies I try to find a kind of ‘ethnographic drive’ of historic knowledge achieved in the field and thus I argue that this kind of insight may be the crucial part of understanding and reconstructing the newest history in such places and its local conditions.

Keywords

EN

oral history; ethnographical sources; interpretation; historical fact; history of countryside; the Torghut; Mongolia

• Publisher: Wydawnictwo Polskiego Towarzystwa Historycznego
• Journal: Rocznik Antropologii Historii
• Year: 2015
• Issue: 8, Antropologia i historia
• Pages: 59–90

Contributors

author

Rakowski Tomasz

• Uniwersytet Warszawski