Russia Against Ukraine Before the European Court of Human Rights. The Empire Strikes Back?

• Authors: Milena Ingelevič-Citak

Abstracts

EN

In July 2021, Russia submitted its first inter-state complaint against Ukraine to the European Court of Human Rights. It was an unexpected and intriguing step of the Russian government, especially since many of the presented allegations are linked to the events that initiated the Russian-Ukrainian conflict. Referring to the hostilities that began in 2014, the international community was, in principle, unanimous in assessing who the aggressor was. The focus of this research is the strategy of the Russian Federation in its recently initiated legal battle before the Strasbourg Court. This paper presents an attempt to outline the possible motives for taking such a step. Moscow's position on this case is particularly puzzling, as some of the allegations concern the Crimean Peninsula, widely recognized under international law as territory occupied by Russia. In spite of that, doubt arises about the strategic objectives of the Russian authorities in the conflict with Ukraine; the question is whether the actions taken by Russia fall within the scope of its previous strategy or if there has been a new turn in the matter. The first part of this paper outlines the background of the given conflict, the second details Russian policy after the annexation of Crimea, and the third, which is crucial for the formulating of conclusions, presents considerations on Russia's possible motivation and goals in filing a complaint to the European Court Human Rights. The research was conducted mainly based on the merits of the complaint, the statements of the representatives of Russia and Ukraine in the matter, the author's observations, and practitioners' considerations.

Keywords

EN

Russian-Ukrainian conflict; European Court of Human Rights; the annexation of the Crimean Peninsula; the policy of the Russian Federation; lawfare; inter-state case

• Publisher: Wydawnictwo Adam Marszałek
• Journal: Polish Political Science Yearbook
• Year: 2022
• Issue: 1(51)
• Pages: 7-29

Dates

published

2022

Contributors

author

Milena Ingelevič-Citak

• Jagiellonian University

• https://orcid.org/0000000325854814

References

• AG Lawyer Newspaper. (2017, July 14). Двойные стандарты в отношении России? https://www.advgazeta.ru/novosti/dvoynye-standarty-v-otnoshenii-rossii
• Agreement (2003, January 23) between the Russian Federation and Ukraine on the state borders. http://zakon4.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/643_157
• Agreement (2014, March 11) between the Russian Federation and the Republic of Crimea on accession of the Republic of Crimea into the Russian Federation and forming new subjects within the Russian Federation. http://www.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/20605
• Barysheva, E., & Goncharenko, R. (2019, March 17). ‘Pięć lat po aneksji Krymu. Co zostało z początkowej euforii?’. https://www.dw.com/pl/pi%C4%99%C4%87-lat-po-aneksji-krymu-co-zosta%C5%82o-z-pocz%C4%85tkowej-euforii/a-47948859
• Beehner, L., Collins, L., Ferenzi, S., et al. (2018). Analyzing the Russian Way of War: Evidence from the 2008 Conflict with Georgia. A Contemporary Battlefield Assessment by the Modern War Institute. https://mwi.usma.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Analyzing-the-Russian-Way-of-War.pdf
• Bowring, B. (2020). Russia and the European Convention (or Court) of Human Rights: The End? Revue Québécoise de Droit International on the 70 years of the European Convention of Human Rights. Hors-série. https://www.sqdi.org/fr/russia-and-the-european-convention-or-court-of-human-rights-the-end
• Chernohorenko, I. (2021, July 30). How Russia will try to sue Ukraine in the European Court of Human Rights. http://euromaidanpress.com/2021/07/30/how-russia-will-try-to-sue-ukraine-in-the-european-court-of-human-rights
• Commission of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea on holding the all-Crimean referendum. (2014, March 16). Результаты общекрымского референдума. https://www.rada.crimea.ua/referendum-resultaty
• Council of Europe. (1950). Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. Council of Europe Treaty Series, 005.
• Council of Europe. (2013, June 24). Protocol No. 15 amending the Convention on the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. Council of Europe Treaty Series, 123.
• ECHR Case Law. (2021, August 28). Russia v. Ukraine with inter state application. Allegations of murder, kidnapping, etc. Request for interim measures and rejection for lack of serious threat and risk of irreparable damage. COM. https://www.echrcaselaw.com/en/echr-decisions/russia-v-ukraine-with-inter-state-application-allegations-of-murder-kidnapping-etc-request-for-interim-measures-and-rejection-for-lack-of-serious-threat-and-risk-of-irreparable-damage
• European Commission. (n.d.). Russian import ban on EU products. https://ec.europa.eu/food/horizontal-topics/international-affairs/eu-russia-sps-issues/russian-import-ban-eu-products_en
• European Court of Human Rights. (2021, July 23). Inter-State applications by date of introduction of the applications. https://echr.coe.int/Documents/InterState_applications_ENG.pdf
• European Court of Human Rights. (2021, July 23). Inter-State application brought by Russia against Ukraine. HUDOC, Press Release 240(2021). https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/app/conversion/pdf/?library=ECHR&id=003-7085775-9583164&filename=Inter-State%20case%20brought%20by%20Russia%20against%20Ukraine.pdf
• European Court of Human Rights. (2021, October 18). Rules of Court. Registry of the Court. Strasbourg. https://www.echr.coe.int/Pages/home.aspx?p=basictexts/rules&c=
• European Court of Human Rights (2011, September 20). OAO Neftyanaya Kompaniya Yukos v. Russia, App. No. 14902/04.
• European Court of Human Rights (2013, July 4). Anchugov and Gladkov v. Russia. App. No. 11157/04 and 15162/05.
• European Court of Human Rights. (n.d.). Case of Ukraine and the Netherlands v. Russia, App. No. 8019/16, 43800/14 and 28525/20).
• European Court of Human Rights. (n.d.). Case of Ukraine v. Russia (IV), App No. 42410/15.
• European Court of Human Rights. (n.d.). Case of Ukraine v. Russia (re Crimea), App. No. 20958/14.
• European Court of Human Rights. (n.d.). Case of Ukraine v. Russia (VI), App. No. 70856/16.
• European Court of Human Rights. (n.d.). Case of Ukraine v. Russia, App. No. 10691/21.
• European Court of Human Rights. (n.d.). Grand Chamber Decision. (2001, December 12). Case of Banković and others v. Belgium, App. No. 52207/99.
• European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber Judgements. (2004, July 8). Case of Ilaşcu and others v. Moldova and Russia, App. No. 48787/99.
• Federal Law. (2015, December 14). О внесении изменений в Федеральный конституционный закон „О Конституционном Суде Российской Федерации”. No. 7-FKZ. https://www.rg.ru/2015/12/15/ks-site-dok.html
• Federal Law. (2021, July 1). О внесении изменений в Федеральный закон „О прокуратуре Российской Федерации”. No. 265-FZ. http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/Document/View/0001202107010042
• Federation Council of Federal Assembly of Russia. (2021, March 1). Resolution No. 48-SF "On the use of Russian Federation Military Forces on the territory of Ukraine". http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/Document/View/0001201403010001
• Foreign Ministry of the Russian Federation. (2021, July 22). Foreign Ministry Statement on the interstate claim brought by Russia against Ukraine with the European Court of Human Rights. https://www.mid.ru/foreign_policy/news/-/asset_publisher/cKNonkJE02Bw/content/id/4825996?p_p_id=101_INSTANCE_cKNonkJE02Bw&_101_INSTANCE_cKNonkJE02Bw_languageId=en_GB
• Fox, G.H. (2015). Intervention by Invitation. In M. Weller (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook on the Use of Force. Oxford University Press.
• Garlicki, L. (2014). Jurysdykcja i odpowiedzialność państw (nowe elementy w orzecznictwie Europejskiego Trybunału Praw Człowieka). Gdańskie Studia Prawnicze, XXXI, 121–132.
• General Prosecutor’s Office of the Russian Federation. (2021, July 22). Навигация. Поиск по новостям – Генеральная прокуратура Российской Федерации. https://epp.genproc.gov.ru/web/gprf/mass-media/news/archive?item=63838459
• Global Conflict Tracker. (n.d.). https://www.cfr.org/global-conflict-tracker/conflict/conflict-ukraine
• Gould-Davies, D., (2020). Russia, the West and Sanctions. Survival: Global Politics and Strategy, 62(1), 7–28.
• Herkel, A. (2017). The new Ukrainian law on education: a major impediment to the teaching of national minorities' mother tongues. Council of Europe, Committee on Culture, Science, Education and Media. https://pace.coe.int/en/files/24125/html
• (2010, July 22). Advisory Opinion on the Accordance with international law of the unilateral declaration of independence in respect of Kosovo. ICJ Reports, 2010.
• ru. (2021, July 21). роллинг международного масштаба: политологи об иске России к Украине в ЕСПЧ. https://www.infox.ru/news/283/260062-trolling-mezdunarodnogo-masstaba-politologi-ob-iske-rossii-k-ukraine-v-espc
• Ingelevič-Citak, M. (2015). Crimean conflict – from the perspectives of Russia, Ukraine, and Public International Law. International and Comparative Law Review, 15(2), 23–45. https://doi.org/10.1515/iclr-2016-0034
• International Crisis Group. (2021, May 26). Commentary Europe & Central Asia: Enhancing Prospects for Peace in Ukraine. https://www.crisisgroup.org/europe-central-asia/eastern-europe/ukraine/enhancing-prospects-peace-ukraine
• Kittrie, O.F. (2016). Lawfare: Law as a Weapon of War. Oxford University Press. DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190263577.001.0001
• Kowalczewska, K. (2014). Lawfare: Inter Arma… Leges Arma? Międzynarodowe Prawo Humanitarne, 2014(5), 38–53.
• Kozenko, D., & Kuryanova, I. (2014, April 15). Смешные санкции, которые могут довести до слез. https://fn-volga.ru/news/view/id/106215
• Lebedeva-Romanova, E., & Skomorovskaya, N. (2017, July 14). Двойные стандарты в отношении России? Адвокатская газета Орган Федеральной палаты адвокатов РФ. https://www.advgazeta.ru/novosti/dvoynye-standarty-v-otnoshenii-rossii/
• Leptev, P. (2015, April 18). The Internet-conference of the Russian Federation representative accredited to the European Court of Human Rights. https://www.garant.ru/interview/10125/
• Lester, A. (2011). The European Court of Human Rights after 50 Years. In J. Christoffersen, & M.R. Madsen (Eds.), The European Court of Human Rights between Law and Politics (pp. 98–115). Oxford University Press.
• Lezhneva, L. (2021, July 22). Не забытое старое: почему Россия подала в ЕСПЧ жалобу против Украины. https://iz.ru/1195463/liubov-lezhneva/ne-zabytoe-staroe-pochemu-rossiia-podala-v-espch-zhalobu-protiv-ukrainy
• Mälksoo, L. (2017). Introduction: Russia, Strasbourg, and the paradox of a human rights backlash. In L. Mälksoo, & W. Benedek (Eds.), Russia and the European Court of Human Rights: The Strasbourg Effect. Cambridge University Press. DOI: 10.1017/9781108235075.003
• Marxsen, Ch. (2014). The Crimea Crisis: an International Law Perspective. MPIL Paper Zeitschrift für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht (Heidelberg Journal of International Law), 74(2), 367–391.
• Medvedev, D. (2015, May 22). The Bloomberg Interview. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/b/1a6c7355-b42f-4d2d-83ac-2e4616390973
• Nesterov, B. (2021, July 23). Крымский парламентарий призвал ЕСПЧ признать водную блокаду попыткой геноцида. Политика сегодня. https://polit.info/549175-krymskii-parlamentarii-prizval-espch-priznat-vodnuyu-blokadu-popytkoi-genocida
• Newton, M.A. (2010). Illustrating Illegitimate Lawfare. Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law, 43(1). https://scholarlycommons.law.case.edu/jil/vol43/iss1/16
• OSCE (2014, March 7). Attempt to visit Crimea aborted at Armyansk crossing. https://www.osce.org/fsc/116201
• Plotnikov, O. (2021, August 24). The proceedings flow while water does not: Russia's claims concerning the North Crimean Canal in Strasbourg. EJIL Talk. https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-proceedings-flow-while-water-does-not-russias-claims-concerning-the-north-crimean-canal-in-strasbourg
• Public Relations Unit, ECHR. (2020). Overview 1959–2019. https://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Overview_19592019_ENG.pdf
• Pushkov, A., (2021, July 13). Post on Telegram. https://t.me/alexey_pushkov/4257
• Putin, V. (2014, March 4). Владимир Путин ответил на вопросы журналистов о ситуации на украине. Президент России. http://www.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/20366
• Putin, V. (2021, July 12). об историческом единстве русских и украинцев. http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/66181
• Putin, V. (2021, March 1). Владимир Путин внёс обращение в Совет Федерации Федерального Собрания Российской Федерации. http://www.kremlin.ru/news/20353
• Rankin, J. (2019, May 17). Council of Europe votes to maintain Russia's membership. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/may/17/council-of-europe-votes-to-maintain-russia-membership-crimea
• Regnum (2019, May 19). Зорькин: ЕСПЧ вводит двойные стандарты. https://regnum.ru/news/polit/2629941.html
• Resolution No. 1727-6/14 'On the declaration of independence of Autonomous Republic of Crimea and the city of Sevastopol'. Supreme Council of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 11 March 2014. http://crimea.gov.ru/act/11726
• Roter, P. (2017). Russia in the Council of Europe: Participation à la carte. In L. Mälksoo, & W. Benedek (Eds.), Russia and the European Court of Human Rights: The Strasbourg Effect. Cambridge University Press. DOI: 10.1017/9781108235075.004
• Russian Federation Legislative Supportive System. (n.d.). О внесении изменений в Федеральный закон ‘О прокуратуре Российской Федерации’. https://sozd.duma.gov.ru/bill/1183775-7
• ru. (2014, June 19). Российско-украинская граница. Досье. https://tass.ru/info/1267817
• Tiefenbrun, S.W. (2010). Semiotic Definition of Lawfare. Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law, 43(1). https://scholarlycommons.law.case.edu/jil/vol43/iss1/3
• UN General Assembly Resolution No. 3314, Definition of Aggression, UN Doc. A/Res/3314 (XXIX). (1974, December 14). https://undocs.org/en/A/RES/3314(XXIX)
• United Nations. (1949, August 12). The IV Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War of 12 August 1949, 75 United Nations Treaty Series, 287.
• United Nations. (2006, December 20). International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance. United Nations Treaty Series, 2716.
• (2017, October 19). Unrepresented Nations & People Organization. 'Crimean Tatars'. https://unpo.org/members/7871
• UNSTAT Metadata. (n.d.). https://unstats.un.org/sdgs/metadata/files/Metadata-16-10-01.pdf
• Vidmar, J. (2015). The Annexation of Crimea and the Boundaries of the Will of the People. German Law Journal, 16(3). DOI: 10.1017/S2071832200020903
• Vlasenko, V. (2021, July 26). Россия против Украины в ЕСПЧ: чего добивается Москва, и какие у нее шансы? DW. https://www.dw.com/ru/rossija-protiv-ukrainy-v-espch-chego-dobivaetsja-moskva-i-kakie-u-nee-shansy/a-58646206
• Zorkin, V. (2010, October 29). Предел уступчивости. Российская газета, 5325(246). https://rg.ru/2010/10/29/zorkin.html

Identifiers

DOI

10.15804/ppsy202206

Biblioteka Nauki

2056867