Digitization of government as a global trend of the future: implementation of the “electronic state” policy (on the example of Ukraine)

• Authors: Serhii Hrytsai

Abstracts

EN

Digitalization of public services is a global trend throughout the civilized world. Progressive governments of developed countries are actively implementing initiatives that have been given a very young acronym – GovTech. These are the latest digital technology solutions that make the work of the state more efficient and the lives of citizens easier. Implementation of the GovTech policy is a priority for many international projects and programs: Lisbon Council, Digital Europe, European Blockchain Partnership (EBP), International Association for Trusted Blockchain Applications (INATBA), DT4UA. The purpose of the article is to form a general vision of the current trend of GovTech policy implementation, using Ukraine as an example for the period of 2020-2023. In order to achieve the goal and formulate reasonable results, the study was structured in three sections: 1) Digitalization of Ukraine: introduction of modern digital technologies; 2) Ukraine’s participation in international digital projects; 3) Sharing Ukraine’s digitalization experience with other countries. The study has led to a number of conclusions. The ideology of GovTech is a two-vector message to humanity about the future: where instead of analog officials and certificates, “PaperLess” will work, and instead of cash currency “CashLess” – CBDC / cryptocurrency in a smartphone. Digital public services in a smartphone, and even a citizen’s passport, are already GovTech realities confirmed by the Ukrainian digital project “DIJA”. Ukraine’s successful experience in forming a GovTech e-state has begun to spread actively in other European Union countries (code name: “DIJA”). This shows a trend towards the development and formation of a precedent for the international GovTech format, in the form of a certain future standard (we are sure that this will be developed and researched). However, this study has shown that there are legal difficulties on the way to creating a precedent for the formation of the international GovTech format in Ukraine. The introduction of the intergovernmental GovTech format requires separate legal regulation and consideration of the issue of a fair balance of bilateral state agreements when it is introduced, which also lack relevant legal developments.

Keywords

EN

GovTech; government technology; e-governance; digital services; PaperLess; CashLess; DIJA; FinTech; virtual assets; cryptocurrency

• Publisher: Wydawnictwo Adam Marszałek
• Journal: Reality of Politics
• Year: 2023
• Issue: 24
• Pages: 45-81

Dates

published

2023

Contributors

author

Serhii Hrytsai

• Institute of Law and Social Relations of the Open International University of Human Development “Ukraine”

• https://orcid.org/0000000300516149

References

• Akcyz na alkogholj mozhna bude perevirjaty cherez «Diju» [It will be possible to check the excise duty on alcohol through “Diya”]. (2023, January 12). Slovo i Dilo. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/xva02.
• Apple, Its Control Over the iPhone, and The Internet. (2023, January 23). MatthewBall.Vc. Retrieved from: https://www.matthewball.vc/all/applemetaverse.
• Blockchain4Ukraine uvijshlo do konsuljtatyvnoji rady blokchejn-asociaciji INATBA [Blockchain4Ukraine joined the advisory board of the blockchain association INATBA]. (2022, September 26). ForkLog. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/eogwh.
• Chainalysis, T. (2021, June 7). Bitcoin Gains by Country: Who Benefited the Most from the 2020 Boom? Chainalysis. Retrieved from: https://blog.chainalysis.com/reports/bitcoin-gains-by-country-2020/.
• Chainalysis, T. (2022, September 14). 2022 Global Cryptocurrency Adoption Index. Chainalysis. Retrieved from: https://blog.chainalysis.com/reports/2022-global-cryptoadoption-index/.
• Dawes, S. S. (2008). The Evolution and Continuing Challenges of E-Governance. Public Administration Review, pp. 86–102.
• Digital Europe Programme (DIGITAL). (2023). F&T Portal. Retrieved from: https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/portal/screen/programmes/digital.
• Digital finance: Agreement reached on European crypto-assets regulation (MiCA). (2022, June 30). European Counsil. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/M3c7R.
• Diia.City. (n.d.). Retrieved from: https://city.diia.gov.ua/.
• eAkcyz. Navishho Ukrajini elektronna marka akcyznogho podatku [eExcise Why does Ukraine have an electronic excise tax stamp?]. (2023, March 15). RBK-Ukrayna. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/l9VDT.
• Fedoriv, A. (2023, April 17). “Mriju, aby ukrajinci zhyly u najzruchnishij krajini svitu”: Interv’ju z ministrom cyfrovoji transformaciji Mykhajlom Fedorovym [“I dream that Ukrainians live in the most convenient country in the world”: Interview with the Minister of Digital Transformation Mykhailo Fedorov]. Vogue. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/bSexs.
• Fefelova, A. (2022, August 27). Cyfrova Ukrajina: 7 faktiv, jaki povynen znaty kozhen – Telekanal I-UA.tv [Digital Ukraine: 7 facts that everyone should know – TV channel I-UA.tv]. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/obZIN.
• Goshovatyuk, A. (2022, July 28). Elektronni hamantsi budut perevedeni na standart IBAN: Podrobytsi. PaySpace Magazine. Retrieved from: https://psm7.com/uk/?p=207060.
• Heath, A. (2021, March 11). The People With Power at Facebook as Its Hardware, Commerce Ambitions Expand. The Information. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/oN8tO.
• Hrytsai, S. (2023). Zmina profiljnogho zakonu pro virtualjni aktyvy: Implementacija jevropejsjkogho reghlamentu MICA [Changing the profile law on virtual assets: Implementation of the European MICA regulation]. Naukovi praci Nacionaljnogho aviacijnogho universytetu, 66(1), pp. 72–82. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.183 72/2307-9061.66.17420.
• Hrytsai, S. (2022a). Virtualjnyj aktyv v Ukrajini je zasobom platezhu? [Is a virtual asset a means of payment in Ukraine?]. Aktualjni problemy polityky, 70, pp. 131–137.
• Hrytsai, S. (2022b). Nacionaljna komisija z cinnykh paperiv ta fondovogho rynku jak sub’jekt administruvannja virtualjnykh aktyviv v Ukrajini [The National Securities and Stock Market Commission as a subject of administration of virtual assets in Ukraine]. Naukovyj visnyk publichnogho ta pryvatnogho prava, 1, pp. 86–92.
• Hrytsai, S. (2022c). Nacionaljnyj bank Ukrajiny jak sub’jekt administruvannja virtualjnykh aktyviv v Ukrajini [The National Bank of Ukraine as a subject of administration of virtual assets in Ukraine]. Pravo ta derzhavne upravlinnja. Zbirnyk naukovykh pracj, 1, pp. 87–93.
• Hrytsai, S. (2022d). Porjadok otrymannja dozvolu na nadannja poslugh, pov’jazanykh z virtualjnymy aktyvamy v Ukrajini [The procedure for obtaining permission to provide services related to virtual assets in Ukraine]. Naukovi praci Mizhreghionaljnoji akademiji upravlinnja personalom: Jurydychni nauky, 62(2), pp. 11–17.
• Hrytsai, S. (2022e). Pravovyj rezhym virtualjnykh aktyviv v Ukrajini [Legal regime of virtual assets in Ukraine]. Juris Europensis Scientia, 2, pp. 65–68.
• Hrytsai, S. (2022f). Uchasnyky rynku virtualjnykh aktyviv v Ukrajini [Participants of the virtual assets market in Ukraine]. Dniprovsjkyj naukovyj chasopys publichnogho upravlinnja, psykhologhiji, prava, 3, pp. 152–157.
• Hrytsai, S. (2022g). Cyfrova valjuta centraljnykh bankiv – zaghrozy ta vyklyky [Digital currency of central banks – threats and challenges]. Aktualjni problemy vitchyznjanoji jurysprudenciji, 1, pp. 144–149.
• Hrytsai, S. (2022h). Cyfrova valjuta centraljnykh bankiv: Nestandartnyj metodologhichnyj pidkhid u pravovomu poli Ukrajiny [Digital currency of central banks: Nonstandard methodological approach in the legal field of Ukraine]. Filosofsjki ta metodologhichni problemy prava, 23(1), pp. 25–34.
• Hrytsai, S. (2022i). Cyfrova valjuta centraljnykh bankiv-Suchasnyj oghljad [Central Bank Digital Currency-A Contemporary Review]. Jurydychnyj bjuletenj, 24, pp. 84–91.
• Hrytsai, S. (2022j). Cyfrova ghryvnja-Stanovlennja [Digital hryvnia-Formation]. Aktualjni problemy polityky, 69, pp. 138–143.
• Hrytsai, S. (2022k). Cyfrovi ghroshi v Ukrajini – CBDC? [Digital money in Ukraine – CBDC?] Jurydychnyj naukovyj elektronnyj zhurnal, 4, pp. 247–249.
• Hrytsai, S. (2023l). Classification of virtual assets in Ukraine. Journal of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine, 30(1), pp. 135–152.
• Indeks cyfrovoji transformaciji reghioniv Ukrajiny: Pidsumky 2022 roku [Index of digital transformation of regions of Ukraine: Results of 2022]. (2023). Ministerstvo cyfrovoji transformaciji Ukrajiny. Retrieved from: https://bit.ly/3ly24TR.
• Kabinet Ministriv Ukrajiny [cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine] (2023). Elektronna tovarnotransportna nakladna (e-TTN) stane obovʼjazkovoju z 1 serpnja 2023 roku [Electronic waybill (e-TTN) will become mandatory from August 1, 2023]. Urjadovyj portal. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/dzA0n.
• Komitet z pytanj cyfrovoji transformaciji [Committee on Digital Transformation] (2023). Komitet z pytanj cyfrovoji transformaciji informuje pro pidsumky roboty za 2022 rik ta plany na 2023 rik [The Committee on Digital Transformation informs about the results of work for 2022 and plans for 2023]. Pres-sluzhba Aparatu Verkhovnoji Rady Ukrajiny [Press service of the Apparatus of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine]. Retrieved from: https://www.rada.gov.ua/news/news_kom/231970.html.
• Marszałek-Kawa, J., Plecka, D. (ed). (2019). The Dictionary of Political Knowledge. Toruń: Wydawnictwo Adam Marszałek.
• Matthew, B. (2020, January 13). The Metaverse: What It Is, Where to Find it, and Who Will Build It. MatthewBall.Vc. Retrieved from: https://www.matthewball.vc/all/themetaverse.
• Meljnyk, T. (2022, August 25). IPhone za kryptu. Slidom za «Fokstrot» ta WOG pryjmaty oplatu v krypti planujutj desjatky biznesiv. Navishho jim ce (znovu). [iPhone for crypto. Following Foxtrot and WOG, dozens of businesses are planning to accept payment in crypto. Why would they (again)]. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/e1g59.
• Mincyfra z partneramy zapuskajutj pilotnyj proekt, jakyj dopomozhe v rozrobci e-ghryvni [The Ministry of Digitization and partners are launching a pilot project that will help in the development of the e-hryvnia]. (2021, December 15). Ministerstvo cyfrovoji transformaciji Ukrajiny [Ministry of Digital Transformation of Ukraine]. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/Ux6Oc.
• Ministerstvo cyfrovoji transformaciji Ukrajiny [Ministry of Digital Transformation of Ukraine] (2022a). Cyfrova Jevropa. Use pro mozhlyvosti na €6 mlrd dlja ukrajinciv. Ministerstvo cyfrovoji transformaciji Ukrajiny [Digital Europe. All about €6 billion opportunities for Ukrainians. Ministry of Digital Transformation of Ukraine]. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/wytlW.
• Ministerstvo cyfrovoji transformaciji Ukrajiny [Ministry of Digital Transformation of Ukraine] (2022b, July 4). Mincyfra zapuskaje Digital4Freedom-Mizhnarodnu iniciatyvu strimkogho vidnovlennja ta rozvytku Ukrajiny cherez innovaciji ta cyfrovizaciju [The Ministry of Digital Affairs launches Digital4Freedom-an international initiative for the rapid recovery and development of Ukraine through innovation and digitalization]. Ministerstvo cyfrovoji transformaciji Ukrajiny [Ministry of Digital Transformation of Ukraine]. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/uexAW.
• Ministerstvo cyfrovoji transformaciji Ukrajiny [Ministry of Digital Transformation of Ukraine] (2022c, December 22). Opanuvaty blokchejn: Mincyfra zapuskaje masshtabnyj bezoplatnyj kurs iz kryptoghramotnosti [Master the blockchain: the Ministry of Digital is launching a large-scale free crypto-literacy course]. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/FC5oJ.
• Mori, J. E. (2022, January 19). Shho take metavsesvit i koly my vzhe zmozhemo v njogho zanurytysj [What is the metauniverse and when will we be able to immerse ourselves in it]. Suspiljne | Novyny. Retrieved from: https://suspilne.media/198748-so-takemetavsesvit-i-koli-mi-vze-zmozemo-v-nogo-zanuritis/?
• Nacionaljnyj Bank Ukrajiny [National Bank of Ukraine]. (2019). Analitychna zapyska za rezuljtatamy pilotnogho proektu “E-ghryvnja.” [Analytical note on the results of the pilot project “E-hryvnia.”]. Nacionaljnyj Bank Ukrajiny [National Bank of Ukraine]. Retrieved from: https://bank.gov.ua/ua/files/pXFPBARsHQjfnAV.
• Nam neobkhidno neghajno zavershyty leghalizaciju virtualjnykh aktyviv v Ukrajini – viceprem’jer Fedorov [We need to immediately complete the legalization of virtual assets in Ukraine – Deputy Prime Minister Fedorov]. (2022, November 29). InterfaxUkraine. Retrieved from: https://interfax.com.ua/news/interview/875292.html [in Ukraine].
• Oghljad ukrajinsjkogho fintekh-sektoru [Overview of the Ukrainian fintech sector]. (2022, October 27). UkraineInvest. Retrieved from: https://ukraineinvest.gov.ua/uk/news/27-10-22/ Open Data Watchdog - Nabory ta resursy [Kits and resources]. (2023). Clarity Project. Retrieved from: https://wd.clarity-project.info/.
• Osvitnij projekt z kryptoghramotnosti ta blokchejnu [Educational project on cryptography and blockchain]. (2023). Dija. Cyfrova Osvita. Retrieved from: https://osvita.diia.gov.ua/crypto-and-blockchain.
• Podatkovyj kodeks Ukrajiny [Tax Code of Ukraine], Pub. L. No. 2755– VI (2010). Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/go/2755-17.
• Poslughy onlajn na portali Dija [Online services on the Diya portal]. (2023). Dija. https://diia.gov.ua/services.
• Pro platizhni poslughy [About payment services], Pub. L. No. 1591– IX (2021). Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/go/1591-20.
• Pro virtualjni aktyvy [About virtual assets], Pub. L. No. 2074– IX (2022). Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/go/2074-20.
• Pro vnesennja zmin do dejakykh normatyvno-pravovykh aktiv Nacionaljnogho banku Ukrajiny z pytanj reghuljuvannja vypusku ta obighu elektronnykh ghroshej [On the introduction of changes to some normative legal acts of the National Bank of Ukraine on issues of regulation of the issue and circulation of electronic money], Pub. L. No. 481 (2010). Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/go/z1336-10.
• Pro vnesennja zmin do Podatkovogho kodeksu Ukrajiny ta dejakykh inshykh zakoniv Ukrajiny shhodo osoblyvostej opodatkuvannja pidpryjemnycjkoji dijaljnosti elektronnykh rezydentiv [On making changes to the Tax Code of Ukraine and some other laws of Ukraine regarding the peculiarities of taxation of business activities of electronic residents], Pub. L. No. 2654– IX (2022). Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/go/2654-20.
• Pro zatverdzhennja Polozhennja pro vypusk elektronnykh ghroshej ta zdijsnennja platizhnykh operacij z nymy [On the approval of the Regulation on the issuance of electronic money and the implementation of payment transactions with it], Pub. L. No. 210 (2022). Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/go/v0210500-22.
• Proekt Zakonu pro vnesennja zmin do Podatkovogho kodeksu Ukrajiny ta dejakykh inshykh zakonodavchykh aktiv Ukrajiny shhodo osoblyvostej opodatkuvannja pidpryjemnycjkoji dijaljnosti elektronnykh rezydentiv [Draft Law on Amendments to the Tax Code of Ukraine and some other legislative acts of Ukraine regarding the peculiarities of taxation of business activities of electronic residents], no. 2654–IX, Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (2022). Retrieved from: https://itd.rada.gov.ua/billInfo/Bills/Card/25973.
• Proekt Zakonu Pro vnesennja zmin do Podatkovogho kodeksu Ukrajiny shhodo opodatkuvannja operacij z virtualjnymy aktyvamy [Draft Law on Amendments to the Tax Code of Ukraine on Taxation of Transactions with Virtual Assets], no. 7150, Retrieved from: Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (2022). https://itd.rada.gov.ua/billInfo/Bills/Card/39211.
• Taskombank. (2023a). Pilotnyj projekt ghryvnevykh elektronnykh ghroshej [Pilot project of hryvnia electronic money] (p. 28). Taskombank. Retrieved from: https://tascombank.ua/files/TASCOMBANK_Pilot_Report_UA.pdf.
• Taskombank. (2023b, January 13). Taskombank u zviti shhodo pilotu z vypusku elektronnykh ghroshej rekomenduje vprovadzhennja blokchejnu dlja zminy platizhnogho landshaftu Ukrajiny [In the report on the pilot for the issuance of electronic money, Taskombank recommends the introduction of blockchain to change the payment landscape of Ukraine]. TAS. Taskombank. Retrieved from: https://tascombank.ua/news/63c12725fa1085001242d53d.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023a, January 6). Stvorjujemo zruchnyj derzhavnyj servis dlja biznesu. Teper na portali Dija mozhna otrymaty vytjagh z Jedynogho derzhavnogho rejestru (JeDR) [We create a convenient state service for business. Now on the Diya portal you can get an extract from the Unified State Register (USR)]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3687.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023b, January 19). Mincyfra ta urjad Estoniji rozrobyly analogh Diji-Zastosunok mRiik [The Ministry of Digital Affairs and the Government of Estonia have developed an analogue of Action-the mRiik application]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3732.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023c, January 20). USAID nadaje $650 tysjach na masshtabuvannja Diji u sviti [USAID provides $650,000 to scale Action around the world]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3740.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023d, February 10). USAID vydilytj 60 mln dolariv na posylennja kiberbezpeky Ukrajiny [USAID will allocate 60 million dollars to strengthen Ukraine’s cyber security]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3811.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023e, February 20). Jevrosojuz vydiljaje 17,4 mln jevro na cyfrovi zminy v Ukrajini [The European Union allocates 17.4 million euros for digital changes in Ukraine]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3833.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023f, March 17). Proghrama DT4UA oficijno startuvala. Dlja jiji realizaciji Ukrajina otrymala 17,4 mln na rozvytok e-poslu [The DT4UA program has officially started. For its implementation, Ukraine received 17.4 million for the development of e-ambassador]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3915.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023g, March 22). Novi mozhlyvosti dlja rozvytku govtech-iniciatyv: Mincyfra pidpysala Memorandum pro spivpracju z Lisabonsjkoju radoju [New opportunities for the development of govtech initiatives: the Ministry of Digital Affairs signed a Memorandum of Cooperation with the Lisbon Council]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3926.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023h, March 22). Rozshyrjujemo spivpracju: Ukrajina ta Velyka Brytanija pidpysaly Ughodu pro cyfrovu torghivlju [We are expanding cooperation: Ukraine and Great Britain signed an Agreement on digital trade]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3924.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023i, March 27). Didzhytalizacija tryvaje: U Kyjevi vidbuvsja forum lideriv cyfrovoji transformaciji [Digitization continues: A forum of digital transformation leaders took place in Kyiv]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3937.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023j, March 29). Ukrajinsjkyj ta svitovyj biznesy obyrajutj Dija.City. Prostir nalichuje vzhe piv tysjachi kompanij [Ukrainian and global businesses choose Diya.City. The space already has half a thousand companies]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3941.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023k, April 3). Na krok blyzhche do cyfrovogho bezvizu: Dija.Pidpys vidpovidaje vymogham JeS. Doluchajtesja do beta-testu [One step closer to digital visa-free: Diya.Signature meets EU requirements. Join the beta test]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3951.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023l, April 13). Відкритість та доступність даних: Clarity Project запускає сервіс Open Data Watchdog [Openness and availability of data: Clarity Project launches Open Data Watchdog service]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3974.
• Telegram: Contact @mintsyfra. (2023m, April 19). Ministerstva ta orghany vlady stvorjuvatymutj novi rejestry na specialjnij Platformi [Ministries and authorities will create new registers on a special Platform]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/mintsyfra/3993.
• Telegram: Contact @yzheleznyak. (2022, October 6). Zakonoproekt #5270: Jak pracjuje e-rezydenstvo [Bill #5270: How e-residency works]. Retrieved from: https://t.me/yzheleznyak/2628.
• The global market of Govtech solutions: Analytical overview. (2023). Kreston Ukraine. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/ERxHc.
• TOP-10 podij na ukrajinsjkomu fintekh-rynku v 2022 roci [TOP-10 events on the Ukrainian fintech market in 2022]. (2022, December 29). Fintech Insider. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/KXnF7.
• U Mincyfri rozpovily pro robotu nad reghuljuvannjam kryptorynku [The Digital Ministry talked about the work on regulating the crypto market]. (2022, September 10). ForkLog. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/N7eLe.
• Ukrajina doluchylasja do Proghramy «Cyfrova Jevropa»: Shho ce oznachaje [Ukraine joined the “Digital Europe” Program: What does it mean?]. (2022, September 5). Ministerstvo cyfrovoji transformaciji Ukrajiny [Ministry of Digital Transformation of Ukraine]. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/NRStS.
• Ukrajina pryjednalasja do Jevropejsjkogho Blokchejn Partnerstva v statusi sposterighacha [Ukraine joined the European Blockchain Partnership as an observer]. (2022, June 17). Ministerstvo cyfrovoji transformaciji Ukrajiny [Ministry of Digital Transformation of Ukraine]. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/kYuxh.
• V Ukrajini mozhutj zapustyty mozhlyvistj odruzhytysja-rozluchytysja v metavsesviti – Fedorov [In Ukraine, the possibility to get married and divorced in the metauniverse can be launched – Fedorov]. (2022, November 17). Ekonomichna pravda. Retrieved from: https://www.epravda.com.ua/news/2022/11/17/693952/.
• V Ukrajini pidpysaly dorozhnju kartu z rozvytku blokchejnu, Web3 [In Ukraine, a road map for the development of the blockchain, Web3, was signed]. (2022, November 15). ForkLog. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/1dXRV.
• V Ukrajini ukhvalyly zakon pro e-rezydentstvo-ForkLog UA [In Ukraine, the law on e-residency was adopted-ForkLog UA]. (2022, October 6). ForkLog. Retrieved from: https://forklog.com.ua/v-ukrayini-uhvalyly-zakon-pro-e-rezydentstvo/.
• Vlada Ukrajiny vyvchatyme mozhlyvosti vypusku blokchejn-dyplomiv dlja sproshhennja jikh veryfikaciji v JeS [The authorities of Ukraine will study the possibilities of issuing blockchain diplomas to simplify their verification in the EU]. (2022, December 9). ForkLog. Retrieved from: http://bitly.pl/cEk0y.

Identifiers

DOI

10.15804/rop2023203

Biblioteka Nauki

9200257