Deadly Disease vs. Chronic Illness: Competing Understandings of HIV in the HIV Non-Disclosure Debate

• Authors: Erica Speakman , Dorothy Pawluch

Abstracts

EN

Over the past several decades, understandings of what it means to have contracted the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) have shifted so that an infection once viewed as deadly and ultimately terminal is now largely regarded as chronic and manageable, at least in the West. Yet, the shift has not been complete. There are arenas of discourse where understandings of what health implications HIV carries with it are contested. One such space is the debate concerning the appropriate response to cases of HIV non-disclosure, that is, situations where individuals who are HIV-positive do not disclose their health status to intimate partners. This paper examines the competing constructions of HIV found within this debate, particularly as it has unfolded in Canada. Those who oppose the criminalization of non-disclosure tend to construct HIV as an infection that is chronic and manageable for those who have contracted it, not unlike diabetes. Those who support criminalization have mobilized a discourse that frames the infection as harmful and deadly. We use the case of the HIV non-disclosure debate to make the argument that representations of health conditions can become mired in larger social problems debates in ways that lead to contests over how to understand the fundamental nature of those conditions.

Keywords

EN

HIV/AIDS; Non- Disclosure; Criminalization; Constructionism; Definitional Contests

• Publisher: Uniwersytet Łódzki. Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Łódzkiego
• Journal: Qualitative Sociology Review
• Year: 2021
• Volume: 17
• Issue: 4
• Pages: 24-42

Dates

published

2021

Contributors

author

Erica Speakman

• McMaster University, Canada

• https://orcid.org/0000000301679791

author

Dorothy Pawluch

• McMaster University, Canada

• https://orcid.org/0000000262983239

References

• Adam, Barry D. 2006. “Infectious Behaviour: Imputing Subjectivity to HIV Transmission.” Social Theory and Health 4(2):168-179.
• Adam, Barry D. 2015. “HIV Disclosure as Practice and Public Policy.” Critical Public Health 25(4):386-397.
• Adam, Barry D. et al. 2013. “Impacts of Criminalization on The Everyday Lives of People Living with HIV in Canada.” Sexuality Research and Social Policy 11(1):39-49.
• Alternet.org. 2010. “They’re Trying to Call HIV-Positive People Bioterrorists?” Retrieved April 29, 2015 https://www.alternet.org/2010/04/theyre_trying_to_call_hiv-positive_people_bioterrorists/
• Altheide, David L. and Christopher J. Schneider. 2013. Qualitative Media Analysis. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
• Beaudin, Christy and Susan Chambre. 1996. “HIV/AIDS as a Chronic Disease.” American Behavioral Scientist 39(6):684-706.
• Bell, Ann. 2016. “The Margins of Medicalization: Diversity and Context Through the Case of Infertility.” Social Science & Medicine 156:39-46.
• Berg, Bruce. 2006. Qualitative Research Methods for the Social Sciences. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
• Berger, Peter and Thomas Luckmann. 1967. The Social Construction of Reality. London: Penguin.
• Best, Joel. 2015. “Beyond Case Studies: Expanding the Constructionist Framework for Social Problems Research.” Qualitative Sociology Review 11(2):18-33.
• Bowen, Glenn. 2009. “Document Analysis as a Qualitative Research Method.” Qualitative Research Journal 9(2):27-40.
• Brown, Phil. 1995. “Naming and Framing: The Social Construction of Diagnosis and Illness.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 35:34-52.
• Canadian AIDS Treatment Information Exchange. 2021. A History of HIV/AIDS. Retrieved February 07, 2021 https://www.catie.ca/en/world-aids-day/history
• Chan, Margaret. 2017. “HIV: From a Devastating Epidemic to a Manageable Chronic Disease.” Pp. 36-41 in 10 Years in Public Health 2007-2017. Geneva: World Health Organization.
• Clairmont, Susan. 2011. “Choose Your Weapon: Sex as Violence, Love or HIV.” Hamilton Spectator, June 29. Retrieved August 13, 2013 https://www.thespec.com/news/hamilton-region/2011/06/29/choose-your-weapon-sex-as-violence-love-orhiv.html
• Conrad, Peter. 2007. The Medicalization of Society: On the Transformation of the Human Condition into Treatable Disorders. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press.
• Conrad, Peter and Alison Angell. 2004. “Homosexuality and Remedicalization.” Society 41(5):32-39.
• Conrad, Peter and Kristin Barker. 2010. “The Social Construction of Illness: Key Insights and Policy Implications.” Journal of Health and Social Behaviour 51(Supplement 1):S67-S79.
• Conrad, Peter and Joseph W. Schneider. 1992. Deviance and Medicalization: From Badness to Sickness. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
• CTV News. 2011. “HIV Killer Declared Dangerous Offender.” Retrieved November 04, 2016 https://www.ctvnews.ca/hiv-killer-declared-dangerous-offender-1.678531
• Elliott, Richard. 1999. Canadian Criminal Law and the Non-Disclosure of HIV Positive Status. Montreal: Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network.
• Figert, Anne E. 1996. Women and the Ownership of PMS: The Structuring of a Psychiatric Disorder. Hawthorne, NY: Aldine de Gruyter.
• Fouchard, Steven. 2014. “HIV-Positive Ottawa Man Acquitted in Nondisclosure Case.” Daily Xtra. Retrieved September 22, 2014 https://xtramagazine.com/power/hiv-positive-ottawa-man-acquitted-in-nondisclosure-case-61288
• Freidson, Eliot. 1970. Profession of Medicine. A Study of the Sociology of Applied Knowledge. Chicago, London: University of Chicago Press.
• French, Martin. 2015. “Counselling Anomie: Clashing Governmentalities of HIV Criminalisation and Prevention.” Critical Public Health 25(4):427-440.
• Galletly, Carol and Steven Pinkerton. 2006. “Conflicting Messages: How Criminal HIV Disclosure Laws Undermine Public Health Efforts to Control the Spread of HIV.” AIDS and Behavior 10(5):451-461.
• Gamson, Josh. 1989. “Silence, Death, and the Invisible Enemy: AIDS Activism and Social Movement ‘Newness.’” Social Problems 36(4):351-367.
• Gidley, Ben. 2017. “Doing Historical and Documentary Research.” Pp. 285-305 in Researching Society and Culture, edited by C. Seale. London: Sage.
• Gillett, James. 2011. A Grassroots History of the HIV/AIDS Epidemic in North America. Spokane, WA: Marquette Books LLC.
• Globe and Mail. 2010. “AIDS and the Duty Not to Infect.” Retrieved August 18, 2013 https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/editorials/aids-and-the-duty-to-not-infect/article1212498/
• Hacking, Ian. 2000. The Social Construction of What? Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
• Hamilton Spectator. 2009. “Killed by a ‘Slow Acting Poison.’” Retrieved August 06, 2013 https://www.thespec.com/news/hamilton-region/2009/04/01/killed-by-a-slow-acting-poison.html
• Harding, Nancy and Colin Palfrey. 1997. The Social Construction of Dementia. London: J. Kingsley.
• Hemsworth, Wade. 2005. “HIV Murder Charges Spark Legal, Ethical Debates; AIDS Advocacy Group Worried about ‘Criminalization’ of a Medical Condition.” Hamilton Spectator, February 26.
• Herek, Gregory and Eric Glunt. 1988. “An Epidemic of Stigma: Public Reactions to AIDS.” American Psychologist 43(11):886-891.
• Hoppe, Trevor. 2014. “From Sickness to Badness: The Criminalization of HIV in Michigan.” Social Science & Medicine 101:139-147.
• Horwath, Glennys. 2007. Death and Dying: Sociological Introduction. Cambridge: Polity Press.
• Jürgens, Rolf et al. 2009. “Ten Reasons to Oppose the Criminalization of HIV Exposure or Transmission.” Reproductive Health Matters 17(34):163-172.
• Kling, Rob et al. 1999. “Assessing Anonymous Communication on the Internet: Policy Deliberations.” The Information Society 15(2):79-90.
• Knight, Rod et al. 2018. “Criminalization of HIV Non-Disclosure: Narratives from Young Men Living in Vancouver, Canada.” PLoS One 13(7):e0201110. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0201110.
• Lazzarini, Zita, Sarah Bray, and Scott Burris. 2002. “Evaluating the Impact of Criminal Laws on HIV Risk Behavior.” Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 30(2):239-253.
• Levine, Martin P. and Richard R. Troiden. 1988. “The Myth of Sexual Compulsivity.” Journal of Sex Research 25(3):347-363.
• Lichtenstein, Bronwen, Kathryn Whetten, and Casey Rubenstein. 2013. “Notify Your Partners-It’s the Law.” Journal of the International Association of Providers of AIDS Care (JIAPAC) 13(4):372-378. doi: 10.1177/2325957413494481.
• Lin, Kai. 2017. “The Medicalization and Demedicalization of Kink: Shifting Contexts of Sexual Politics.” Sexualities 20(3):302-323.
• Lincoln, Yvonna S. 1980. Documentary Analysis and Record Utilization: New Uses for Old Methods. Paper Presented as the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association. Boston, MA.
• Loseke, Donileen. 2003a. Thinking about Social Problems: An Introduction to Constructionist Perspectives. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
• Loseke, Donileen. 2003b. “The Homeless Mentally Ill and Involuntary Hospitalization.” Pp. 146-153 in Social Problems: Constructionist Readings, edited by J. Best and D. Loseke. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
• McCrea, Frances. 1983. “The Politics of Menopause: The ‘Discovery’ of a Deficiency Disease.” Social Problems 31(1):111-123.
• Merminod, Anne. 2009. “The Deterrence Rationale in the Criminalization of HIV/AIDS.” Lex Electronica 3(3):1-34.
• Mykhalovskiy, Eric. 2015. “The Public Health Implications of HIV Criminalization: Past, Current, and Future Research Directions.” Critical Public Health 25(4):373-385.
• Mykhalovskiy, Eric, Jonathan Betteridge, and David McLay. 2010. HIV Non-Disclosure and the Criminal Law: Establishing Policy Options for Ontario. Toronto: Ontario HIV Treatment Network.
• Mykhalovskiy, Eric et al. 2016. “‘Callous, Cold and Deliberately Duplicitous’: Racialization, Immigration and the Representation of HIV Criminalization in Canadian Mainstream Newspapers.” Research Report. Retrieved July 26, 2021 https://ssrn.com/abstract=2874409
• Nguyen, Linda. 2011. “Ontario Man Who Spread HIV to Testify at Hearing.” Postmedia News, May 11. Retrieved September 09, 2013 http://www.nationalpost.com/scripts/Ontario+spread+-testify+hearing/4806836/story.html
• Oakley, Ann. 1984. Captured Wombs: A History of Medical Care of Pregnant Women. New York: Basil Blackwell.
• O’Byrne, Patrick, Alyssa Bryan, and Marie Roy. 2013. “HIV Criminal Prosecutions and Public Health: An Examination of the Empirical Research.” Medical Humanities 39(2):85-90.
• Pawluch, Dorothy. 2016. “Health as a Social Construction.” Pp. 34-54 in Health and Society: Critical Perspectives, edited by J. Gillett, G. Andrews, and M. Savelli. Toronto: Oxford University Press.
• Pawluch, Dorothy. 2019. “On the Unbearable Lightness of Being a Constructionist.” American Sociologist 50(2):204-219.
• Pfohl, Stephen. 1977. “The ‘Discovery’ of Child Abuse.” Social Problems 24(3):310-323.
• Plenty of Fish. 2007. Retrieved September 23, 2014 http://forums.plentyoffish.com/datingPosts6407166.aspx
• Positive Living BC. 2014. “Canada’s Vicious HIV Laws: How the Supreme Court Redefined Safe Sex.” Retrieved September 22, 2014 https://slate.com/technology/2014/05/canada-criminalizes-nondisclosure-of-hiv-status-shifts-responsibility-from-condoms-to-viral-load.html
• Prevention Access Campaign. 2016. “Undetectable = Untransmittable.” Retrieved August 02, 2017 https://www.preventionaccess.org/undetectable
• Queerty. 2010. “Is Canada Really Trying an HIV-Positive Gay Man with Attempted Murder? Yep.” Retrieved August 15, 2017 https://www.queerty.com/is-canada-really-trying-a-hiv-positive-gay-man-with-attempted-murder-yep-20100706
• Samji, Hasina et al. 2013. “Closing the Gap: Increases in Life Expectancy among Treated HIV-Positive Individuals in the United States and Canada.” PLoS ONE 8 (12):e81355. d oi: 1 0.1371/ journal.pone.0081355.
• Scandlyn, Jean. 2000. “When AIDS Became a Chronic Disease.” Western Journal of Medicine 172(2):130-133.
• Scott, Susie. 2006. “The Medicalisation of Shyness: From Social Misfits to Social Fitness.” Sociology of Health and Illness 28(2):133-153. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9566.2006.00485.x.
• Scritchfield, Shirley. 2009. “The Construction of Infertility: From Private Matter to Social Concern.” Pp. 131-146 in Images of Issues: Typifying Contemporary Social Problems, edited by J. Best. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
• Sobal, Jeffrey and Donna Maurer. 1999. Interpreting Weight. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
• Speakman, Erica. 2017. “Constructing an ‘HIV-Killer’: HIV Non-Disclosure and the Techniques of Vilification.” Deviant Behavior 38(4):392-405.
• Spector, Malcolm. 1977. “Legitimizing Homosexuality.” Society 14(5):52-56.
• Spector, Malcolm and John I. Kitsuse. 1977. Constructing Social Problems. Menlo Park, CA: Cummings Publishing Company.
• Stevens, Bethany. 2011. “Interrogating Transability: A Catalyst to View Disability as Body Art.” Disability Studies Quarterly 31(4). doi: 10.18061/dsq.v31i4.
• Swiffen, Amy. 2015. “Bio-Crime: The Criminalization of HIV in Canada.” Law and Governance 17(5):1-6.
• Szasz, Thomas. 1961. “The Uses of Naming and the Origin of the Myth of Mental Illness.” American Psychologist 16(2):59-65.
• Taylor, Paul. 2011. “Should HIV Non-Disclosure Remain a Crime?” Globe and Mail, December 21. Retrieved August 08, 2013 https://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/healthand-fitness/should-hiv-non-disclosure-remain-a-crime/article4085873/
• Tight, Malcolm. 2019. Documentary Research in the Social Sciences. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
• UNAIDS. 2021. Addressing Inequalities and Getting Back on Track to End AIDS by 2030. Report of the Secretary General. Retrieved July 26, 2021 https://hlm2021aids.unaids.org/sg-report/
• Waitzkin, Howard. 1989. “A Critical Theory of Medical Discourse: Ideology, Social Control, and the Processing of Social Context in Medical Encounters.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 30(2):220-239.
• Webel, Allison. 2015. “How HIV Became a Treatable, Chronic Disease.” The Conversation, December 02. Retrieved July 26, 2021 https://theconversation.com/how-hiv-became-a-treatablechronic-disease-51238
• World Health Organization. 2021. Global Progress Report on HIV, Viral Hepatitis and Sexually Transmitted Infections. Geneva: WHO. Retrieved July 26, 2021 https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240027077
• Zola, Irving. 1972. “Medicine as an Institution of Social Control.” Sociological Review 20(4):487-504.

Identifiers

DOI

10.18778/1733-8077.17.4.02

Biblioteka Nauki

2028545