Resolutions of the Sejm of the Republic of Poland are a form of expressing the will of this body (chamber). Resolutions that do not contain legal norms include those that give rise to legal effects (e.g., resolutions on the election of officials of various state authorities), and those that do not give rise to legal effects (are not legally binding), i.e., mandatory resolutions, declarations, appeals, and statements. It is not permitted for the Sejm to adopt a normative resolution that would affect matters reserved for statutes, nor a resolution on the invalidity, non-existence, or suspension of a given normative act (e.g., a statute, decree, or regulation).
Bankowy Fundusz Gwarancyjny (BFG) stanowi podstawowy element polskiej sieci bezpieczeństwa finansowego. W ostatnich latach kształt jego działalności podlegał znacznym modyfikacjom. Zasadne staje się pytanie o kompletność nowego modelu działalności BFG. Celem artykułu jest zidentyfikowanie zadań, o które mogłaby zostać rozwinięta działalność BFG. Dokonano identyfikacji zadań Funduszu, a następnie porównano je z wynikami analizy funkcjonowania 109 systemów gwarantowania depozytów na świecie. Na bazie doświadczeń międzynarodowych wskazać można kilka obszarów, na których działalność BFG może zostać udoskonalona. Obejmują one m.in. wprowadzenie możliwości udzielania pomocy finansowej dla banków, których sytuacja pogorszyła się, zwiększenie poziomu dywersyfikacji inwestycji dokonywanych przez Fundusz lub wzmocnienie działalności informacyjno-edukacyjnej BFG przez obecność w mediach społecznościowych.
EN
The Bank Guarantee Fund (BGF) is a basic element of the Polish financial safety net. In recent years, the shape of its activity has undergone significant modifications. Therefore, questioning the completeness of the new BGF business model becomes justified. The purpose of the article is to identify fields in which the BGF’s activities could be developed. The Fund’s tasks were identified and then compared with the results of an analysis of 109 deposit guarantee systems around the world. Based on the international experience, several areas can be identified where the BGF’s operations can be improved. They include introducing the possibility of providing financial assistance to banks whose situation has worsened, increasing the level of diversification of investments made by the Fund, and strengthening the BGF’s information and education activities through a presence in social media.
Post-crisis bank regulations recognised the need for a creation of a formalized resolution framework which would allow for an efficient resolution of troubled banks, with no or limited use of public funds. However, the resolution schemes are based on complex procedures, which aim at balancing the interests of different stakeholders. The purpose of this paper is to identify and assess the key elements of the resolution framework under the Single Resolution Mechanism (SRM) and the Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive (BRRD), concentrating on the bail-in tool. In particular, the paper attempts to demonstrate that there are some serious economic and social problems, when the resolution procedures are applied to local and regional banks, such as the cooperative sector, illustrating it with the bank resolution experience in Italy.
The subject matter of the article concerns the standardisation of the legal concepts of “Domicile” and of “Residence” in the Resolution (72) 1 adopted by the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on 18 January 1972. The first part of the article presents the nature and the content of the resolution and its annex containing “rules” concerning both concepts. The resolution is not a legally binding instrument and its goal is to influence interpretation of the key legal concepts of “domicile” and of “residence”. The resolution has indented to provide for a unification of these concepts. The next part of the article includes remarks regarding the impact of the resolution on the national legislators and doctrine. The emphasis is put on the role of the concept of “domicile” and “residence” as connecting factors in private international law. The effect of the resolution is discussed in the light of the tendencies of the time, especially standpoint of the Hague Conference on private international law on the use the concept of domicile and the meaning of the term habitual residence.
The subject of this article is an analysis of the functioning models of the claimability of the resolutions of the bodies of companies in terms of the connection of these models with the legal nature of these resolutions. In the case of resolutions of shareholders meetings of companies, the provisions of the Code of Commercial Companies and Partnerships provide for a judicial review of each resolution adopted by that body. A different situation occurs in the case of resolutions of supervisory boards of companies, for which no procedure for pursuing legal actions against them is provided for in the CCC&P. The doctrine and the case law assume that, as a consequence of the application of the principle of unity of civil law, these resolutions can be challenged in court, as can invalid legal transactions. In this case, therefore, the legal nature of the resolution, and thus the determination that it is a legal transaction is crucial for the possibility of its challenging in court.
In addition to the five treaties that form the core of international space law, the resolutions adopted by the United Nations General Assembly have served as a tool for influencing the framework of legal regulations governing space activities by the States. These instruments, which constitute the soft law of international law, have fulfilled different functions depending on the period in which they were adopted. In the period preceding the so-called era of treaty law, the resolutions laid the foundation for the establishment of a binding legal framework to regulate space activities. During the so-called UNGA resolutions era, the States adopted resolutions that served as instruments to shape the principles governing specific aspects of state space activities. Resolutions adopted in the third era, after 2004, have acted as instruments influencing the interpretation of the provisions of space treaties.
Since the initiation of the first compulsory restructuring, resolution comes to the fore as the BGF’s primary responsibility. This intricate and long-term operation necessitates significant financial investment. Therefore, we emphasise that the goal of the research conducted for this study aims primarily to systematize legal measures that apply to financing resolution, with a particular focus on contributions paid to the BGF by obliged entities. Moreover, the aim of this research is to present the separate nature of this financial structure and its specific characteristics at the stage of building relevant funds. Due to the complexity of the presented subject matter, special focus is given to selected aspects of the adopted financing model. The discussion presented here refers only to resolution of banks. The primary research method applied in this study is an analysis of the currently applicable legislation. This study covers the legislation in force and relevant literature. The final section of the article presents a case study which showcases the BGF’s practical approach to addressing resolution processes (including those that have been concluded).
The author analyses two types of parliamentary immunity: non-accountability and inviolability, indicating their features and characteristics. He emphasises that a resolution to refuse consent to subject a Deputy (Senator) to criminal accountability is of a final and permanent nature during the holding of a mandate, and therefore remains coupled to a specific term of office of the House. Asking the Sejm again for consent to prosecute for the same offence could be permissible only if new circumstances have been established which were not previously known to the prosecutor, and which are significant enough to influence a different decision by the Sejm. There is no legal obstacle to the renewal of a motion to waive the immunity of a parliamentarian in the new term of office of the House in relation to the same offence that was the subject of the resolution of the Sejm (Senate) to refuse consent to subject him/her to criminal accountability in the previous term of office.
A resolution of the Sejm consenting to subjection to criminal accountability, detention or arrest of a Deputy is final and may not be revoked by the Sejm by means of another resolution. It is possible to suspend these proceedings at the request of the Sejm if the Deputy has been re-elected to the Sejm, in the case of criminal proceedings instituted against a Deputy on the basis of consent granted by the Sejm of the previous term of office. Proceedings for the consent to subjection to criminal accountability, detention or arrest of a Deputy shall be instituted before the Sejm at the request of an authorised prosecutor or other authorised entity, lodged through the Public Prosecutor General.
The resolution of the Sejm to refuse consent to bringing a Deputy to criminal accountability is not permanent. Such a decision may be revoked at any time. The prosecutor (the Public Prosecutor General) may request that consent to the subjection of a Deputy or a Senator to criminal accountability be reissued. The permanence of the decision to refuse is linked to the permanence of the ruling to discontinue the proceedings following such a decision. The decision to refuse to waive immunity is also not binding (in any case) on the Sejm of the following term of office. In view of the risk of politicisation of the procedures related to the waiver of immunity, some follow-up review of the decision to refuse to waive immunity in successive parliamentary terms is in fact necessary.
The consent of the Sejm to subject a Deputy to criminal accountability, expressed in a resolution, is commonly understood as a permission to take all procedural actions against the Deputy which do not interfere with the sphere covered by the privilege of inviolability. Decisions made by procedural bodies in preliminary proceedings are subject to judicial control. The Marshal of the Sejm does not have any authority to assess in concreto procedural actions in criminal proceedings. The public prosecutor may amend the procedural determination of the act charged against the Deputy (including supplementing the decision to bring charges), but the limits of such actions are determined by the ontological identity (sameness) of the act included in the motion and the resolution of the Sejm.
The resolution of the Sejm on refusal to consent to subjection of a Deputy to criminal accountability is of a permanent nature only within the term of office of the Sejm in which it was adopted. This is the permanence rebus sic stantibus. The reconsideration of the matter of consenting to subjection of a Deputy to criminal accountability is only permissible if new relevant circumstances arise which were not previously known to the Sejm and could not be brought to its attention. The Sejm of the new term of office is not bound by a resolution of the Sejm of the previous term of office refusing to consent to subjection of a Deputy to criminal accountability. Consequently, the prosecutor may again seek consent for prosecution in relation to the same Deputy and an act ontologically identical with the one to which the resolution refusing consent referred.
It is not possible to recognise the admissibility of a waiver of a Deputy’s immunity by the public prosecutor’s office through the application of preventive measures on the basis of future charges other than those specified in the resolution of the Sejm consenting to the waiver of immunity. The reason for this is that the waiver of immunity relates to the particular case specified in the relevant resolution. The waiver of immunity does not constitute a restriction on the Deputy’s right to exercise mandate. It is not possible to apply to a Deputy whose immunity has been waived a preventive measure in the form of a prohibition on contact with other Deputies, as this would impede the proper functioning of the Sejm and the proper exercise of the Deputy’s mandate.
The draft resolutions under consideration were submitted by deputies belonging to various political groups represented in the Sejm, with the expectation that the Sejm would adopt a resolution essentially calling on the Council of Ministers to take steps to withdraw from the Migration Pact or amend it and neutralise its negative consequences by obtaining systemic support from the EU. However, under the current legal framework, it is not possible to withdraw from the Migration Pact (unilaterally renounce it), and failure to implement it may result in liability for violating EU acts. Poland can only attempt to persuade the Commission to take appropriate steps to amend the Migration Pact.
Samo przyznanie inicjatywy uchwałodawczej grupie mieszkańców w niczym nie ogranicza uprawnień samych radnych czy rady, bowiem przedłożenie takiego projektu uchwały skutkować będzie nie obowiązkiem jej przyjęcia, lecz rozpoznania jak każdej inicjatywy. Zatem w tym zakresie nie dochodzi do żadnego pozbawienia czy ograniczenia kompetencji samego organu stanowiącego – rady gminy. Ponadto przyznanie inicjatywy uchwałodawczej również grupie osób posiadających czynne prawo wyborcze nie narusza w sposób istotny prawa, gdyż zawarta kompetencja dla inicjatywy obywatelskiej pozostaje „w granicach prawa” wynikającego z art. 169 ust. 4 Konstytucji RP, rozumianego jako generalne uprawnienie do kształtowania treści statutu.
EN
It must be stated that the voted verdict of the Provincial Administrative Court in Olsztyn is correct; according to the verdict, granting resolution-making initiative to a group of persons who enjoy active electoral rights does not violate the law because the civic resolution-making initiative is within the “limits of law” arising from Art. 169 (4) of the Constitution of the Republic of Poland as a general right to shape the content of a statute. The very granting of resolution-making initiative to a group of residents does not limit in any way the rights of councilors or the council because submission of a draft resolution does not result in the requirement to adopt it but only the requirement to examine it – as in the case of any other initiative. Consequently, there is no deprivation or limitation of the competence of the decisionmaking body – the commune council. Moreover, I believe that questioning the provisions of a statute only on the basis of the claim that they do not have a faithful and detailed origin in an act is an error in the legal art because it is wrong to claim that a commune does not have a detailed basis separately for each provision of its statute while overlooking the general basis of all provisions of statutes contained in the relevant regulations: Art. 164 (4) of the Constitution of the Republic of Poland and Art. 3 (1), Art. 18 (2) (1), Art. 21 (1), and Art. 22 (1) of the Act on commune-level local government. A commune statute can regulate all matters related to the system of government in the commune that are not expressly regulated in the act, as long as it is not contradictory to the provisions of the act. What is more, I believe that not only a group of residents have the right to resolution- making initiative granted in the statute, but also that such a right can be granted to, e.g. a general meeting of an association or a resolution-making body of a political party that has a local unit in the territory of a specific unit of local government.
The study concerns the legal and procedural nature of resolutions adopted by the councils of units running doctoral conducts and habilitation proceedings. Different types of resolutions were analyzed and their features and typology were assessed.
Mimo że tematyka ryzyka podejmowanego przez banki jest szeroko opisywana w literaturze przedmiotu, to jednak zagrożenia napotykane w działalności instytucji sieci bezpieczeństwa finansowego są znacznie rzadziej analizowane. Dobrą okazją do ich bliższego rozpoznania jest pierwsze w historii wdrożenie procedury resolution przez Jednolitą Radę ds. Resolution (organ resolution unii bankowej), zgodnie z wprowadzonymi po kryzysie finansowych 2007+ przepisami. Analiza pozwów wytoczonych w związku z przymusową sprzedażą Banco Popular Español (BPE) do banku Santander jest bowiem cenną lekcją potencjalnych rodzajów ryzyka prawnego, z którym musi się zmierzyć organ resolution. W tym celu dokonano analizy pojęcia ryzyka prawnego, przedstawiono ramy prowadzenia działań antykryzysowych w nowych uwarunkowaniach prawnych oraz przebieg kryzysu w banku BPE. Następnie przeanalizowano konsekwencje resolution BPE przez pryzmat pozwów przeciw przeprowadzonym działaniom.
EN
Although the subject of bank risks is widely described in the banking literature, the dangers encountered in the operations of safety net institutions are less frequently analyzed. A good opportunity for their deeper study is the first implementation of the resolution procedure by the Single Resolution Board (banking union resolution authority) in line with the provisions introduced to the EU legal framework after the financial crisis 2007+. The analysis of the lawsuits connected with the forced sale of the Banco Popular Español to Santander (BPE) offers a valuable lesson on potential legal risks that must be addressed by the resolution authority. For this purpose, the concept of legal risk, the framework for conducting anti-crisis measures in the new legal environment and the course of the BPE crisis have been analyzed. Then, the consequences of BPE’s resolution have been investigated.
The paper focuses on resolutions adopted by the management board and the supervisory board of a joint-stock company to increase the share capital of a public limited company within its authorised capital. The author outlines the origin and nature of the authorised capital, the content and form of the abovementioned resolutions, their legal nature and different types of possible defects in them. Challenging defective resolutions is particularly important in practice. That matter is not regulated explicitly in Polish law. The possible solutions available under Italian and Spanish regulations that are presented indicate that the challenging of defective resolutions of the management board and the supervisory board in capital commercial companies, particularly those adopted in connection with authorised capital, should also be regulated in Poland.
PL
The paper focuses on resolutions adopted by the management board and the supervisory board of a joint-stock company to increase the share capital of a public limited company within its authorised capital. The author outlines the origin and nature of the authorised capital, the content and form of the abovementioned resolutions, their legal nature and different types of possible defects in them. Challenging defective resolutions is particularly important in practice. That matter is not regulated explicitly in Polish law. The possible solutions available under Italian and Spanish regulations that are presented indicate that the challenging of defective resolutions of the management board and the supervisory board in capital commercial companies, particularly those adopted in connection with authorised capital, should also be regulated in Poland.
The article analyzes the cases of two Italian banks - Carige and Banca Popolare di Bari - which received systemic support without the formal initiation of a resolution procedure. A comparison of both interventions shows that EU member states can effectively support failing banks while avoiding the bail-in of bank liabilities by using hybrid mechanisms. The article highlights the need to clarify the rules on resolution and state aid within the EU and underscores the tensions between the theory and practice of the Banking Union.
PL
W artykule przeanalizowano przypadki dwóch włoskich banków: Carige oraz Banca Popolare di Bari, które otrzymały wsparcie systemowe bez formalnego uruchomienia procedury przymusowej restrukturyzacji (resolution). Porównanie obu interwencji pokazuje, że państwa członkowskie mogą skutecznie wspierać upadające banki unikając umorzenia zobowiązań banków (tzw. bail-in), poprzez wykorzystanie mechanizmów hybrydowych. Artykuł wskazuje na potrzebę doprecyzowania zasad resolution i pomocy publicznej w UE oraz podkreśla napięcia między teorią a praktyką Unii Bankowej.
The paper focuses on resolutions adopted by the management board and the supervisory board of a joint-stock company to increase the share capital of a public limited company within its authorised capital. The author outlines the origin and nature of the authorised capital, the content and form of the abovementioned resolutions, their legal nature and different types of possible defects in them. Challenging defective resolutions is particularly important in practice. That matter is not regulated explicitly in Polish law. The possible solutions available under Italian and Spanish regulations that are presented indicate that the challenging of defective resolutions of the management board and the supervisory board in capital commercial companies, particularly those adopted in connection with authorised capital, should also be regulated in Poland.
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.