Financial exclusion can result from incorrect everyday financial risk management. It refers to those individuals who, as a result of financial decisions made in different market conditions, or suffering unfortunate life circumstances, have become excessively indebted and their material status has suddenly deteriorated. In such situation they turn out unattractive for banks and thus suffer exclusion from the financial system. The objective of the article is to present the importance of responsible loan decisions made by households - one of the stakeholder groups of responsible finance - in counteracting financial exclusion. The condition for undertaking a correct loan decision is the access to adequate information as well as having knowledge and financial skills which allow to take proper advantage of such information.
Financial resilience means household capacity to survive financial shocks. The purpose of the article is to identify and present methods for increasing financial resilience as the condition for long-lasting inclusion of households. The following research methods were used: critical analysis of the subject literature, basic statistical methods and the diagnostic survey method. Based on the author’s own research results the areas were identified where due actions should be taken in order to increase financial resilience. They are as follows: emergency fund increase, relation optimization of debt against income, taking advantage of adequate insurance, financial competencies improvement, relational capital formation.
PL
Odporność finansowa oznacza zdolność gospodarstw domowych do przetrwania szoków finansowych. Głównym celem artykułu jest zidentyfikowanie i przedstawienie metod zwiększania odporności finansowej, stanowiącej warunek trwałej inkluzji finansowej gospodarstw domowych. Wykorzystane metody badawcze to krytyczna analiza literatury przedmiotu, proste metody statystyczne oraz metoda sondażu diagnostycznego. Na podstawie wyników badań własnych wskazano obszary, w których powinno się podejmować działania zwiększające odporność finansową. Są to: powiększanie „funduszu awaryjnego”, optymalizowanie relacji zadłużenia do dochodów, korzystanie z odpowiednich ubezpieczeń, doskonalenie kompetencji finansowych, kształtowanie kapitału relacyjnego.
The article presents the following research hypothesis: A young generation of adult children of Poles is a net beneficiary of family financial transfers of a non-returnable nature. The article purposes are as follows: analyzing the scale, frequency, and directions of transferring and receiving financial gifts by akin households. The applied research methods included: critical analysis of the subject literature, simple statistical methods, method of a diagnostic survey. The survey studies, conducted in 2018, have shown that 39.9% of Poles provided financial support to their relatives in the last 6 months, while a smaller percentage (28.6%) of respondents declared that in the same period received a monetary donation from the family. Population under the age of 24 represents the only age group which receives more financial support than actually provides. Private financial transfers are predominantly of an intergenerational nature, as the majority of transfers occur between parents and adult children.
PL
Sformułowana w artykule hipoteza badawcza brzmi: Młode pokolenie dorosłych dzieci Polaków jest beneficjentem netto rodzinnych transferów finansowych o charakterze bezzwrotnym. Wśród celów artykułu znalazło się rozpoznanie skali, częstotliwości oraz kierunków przekazywania i otrzymywania darów finansowych przez spokrewnione gospodarstwa domowe. Wykorzystane metody badawcze to: krytyczna analiza literatury przedmiotu, proste metody statystyczne, metoda sondażu diagnostycznego. Z przeprowadzonych w 2018 r. badań ankietowych wynika, że 39,9% Polaków w ciągu ostatnich 6 miesięcy udzieliło wsparcia finansowego swoim krewnym, zaś mniejszy odsetek (28,6%) respondentów zadeklarował, że w tym okresie otrzymał od rodziny darowiznę pieniężną. Osoby poniżej 24. roku życia stanowią jedyną grupę wiekową, która więcej wsparcia finansowego otrzymuje, niż przekazuje. Prywatne transfery finansowe mają głównie charakter międzypokoleniowy, ponieważ najwięcej przepływów zachodzi między rodzicami a dorosłymi dziećmi.
The crucial instrument, which strengthens the financial resilience of households is represented by loans from family and friends, since they constitute the second popular (23.7%) source of financing unexpected expenses incurred by Poles. The purpose of the article is to present the significance of empathic behaviours, shown in the context of granting family loans, for the financial resilience of households. The following research methods were applied: critical analysis of the subject literature, simple statistical methods and the method of diagnostic survey. The conducted survey studies revealed that approx. 73% of Poles granted a family loan in 2015. Among the most frequent motives of financial support offered to family members the following was listed empathy (34.1% indications). Therefore, emphatic behaviours should be considered as facilitating the strengthening of financial resilience of households.
PL
Istotnym instrumentem wzmacniania odporności finansowej gospodarstw domowych są pożyczki od rodziny i znajomych, gdyż stanowią drugie pod względem popularności (23,7%) źródło finansowania nieprzewidzianych wydatków Polaków. Celem artykułu jest ukazanie znaczenia zachowań empatycznych ujawniających się w kontekście udzielania pożyczek rodzinnych dla odporności finansowej gospodarstw domowych. Wykorzystane metody badawcze to: krytyczna analiza literatury przedmiotu, proste metody statystyczne i metoda sondażu diagnostycznego. Z przeprowadzonych badań ankietowych wynika, że około 73% Polaków udzieliło w 2015 r. pożyczki rodzinnej. Wśród najczęściej wymienianych motywów wsparcia finansowego krewnych znalazła się empatia (34,1% wskazań). Zachowania empatyczne należy zatem uznać za sprzyjające wzmacnianiu odporności finansowej gospodarstw domowych.
Ludzie młodzi wymieniani są wśród podmiotów wrażliwych na wykluczenie finansowe. Oznacza to, że mogą doświadczać problemów w dostępie do produktów i usług finansowych w odpowiedniej dla nich formie. Według da-nych Banku Światowego tylko połowa dorosłych mieszkańców Ziemi dysponuje rachunkiem bankowym, przy czym w grupie wiekowej 15–24 jest już tylko 37% ubankowionych. Do głównych przyczyn wykluczenia finansowego młodych ludzi należy zaliczyć: niskie dochody, wzrastającą stopę bezrobocia, niedosta¬teczną wiedzę i brak świadomości finansowej. Wśród podstawowych obszarów, w jakich prowadzone są działania inkluzyjne skierowane do młodych ludzi, znajdują się przede wszystkim: mikrofinansowanie, oferowanie produktów szytych na miarę, kształtowanie umiejętności finansowych.
The purpose of the article is to diagnose the level of knowledge presented by Poles in the area of retirement problems and to assess the risk awareness associated with their retirement decisions. The assertion that the higher the level of knowledge presented by Poles in the area of retirement problems the more aware they are of the risk associated with their retirement decisions constitutes the research hypothesis of the study. Achieving the identified purpose and verifying the defi ned hypothesis was correlated with the layout of the article and the applied research methods, including: critical analysis of the subject literature, statistical methods, descriptive methods and diagnostic survey method. The empirical data, essential to perform the analysis, originate from nationwide surveys carried out in September 2019 using the CAWI (Computer Assisted Web Interview) method within a representative sample of 818 Poles. The analysis and interpretation of the collected research material allowed for the confi rmation of the adopted research hypothesis.
PL
Celem artykułu jest diagnoza poziomu wiedzy Polaków w obszarze zagadnień emerytalnych oraz ocena świadomości ryzyka, które towarzyszy podejmowanym przez nich decyzjom emerytalnym. W ramach hipotezy badawczej przyjęto, że im wyższy poziom wiedzy Polaków w obszarze zagadnień emerytalnych, tym bardziej są świadomi ryzyka, które towarzyszy podejmowanym przez nich decyzjom emerytalnym. Osiągnięciu wyznaczonego celu oraz weryfikacji postawionej hipotezy podporządkowano układ artykułu oraz wykorzystane metody badawcze, obejmujące: krytyczną analizę literatury przedmiotu, metody statystyczne, opisowe oraz metodę sondażu diagnostycznego. Niezbędne do dokonania analiz dane empiryczne pochodzą z ogólnopolskich badań ankietowych zrealizowanych we wrześniu 2019 r. metodą CAWI (Computer Assisted Web Interview) na reprezentatywnej próbie 818 osób. Analiza i interpretacja zebranego materiału badawczego pozwoliły na potwierdzenie przyjętej hipotezy badawczej.
Theoretical background: Contemporary financial systems have been going through a period of dynamic changes since the beginning of this century. A special role in this process is played by technological innovations, especially the process of digitalization of financial systems, which resulted in the development of FinTech lenders. These entities are active in various segments of the financial services market, including the area of consumer loans (FinTech lenders). The conducted research confirms the dynamic development of FinTech lending activity worldwide and indicates the leading position of Poland among the countries of Central and Eastern Europe in terms of the volume of digital lending. A review of the source literature shows a small number of scientific studies devoted to identifying the reasons underlying the growing interest of consumers in the offer of FinTech lenders. The perceived research gap became the motivation to undertake research addressing this topic in relation to the Polish market of non-banking digital loan services. Purpose of the article: Determining the place and importance of trust and personal innovativeness for consumers’ decisions to use digital loan services offered by FinTech lenders in Poland. Research methods: Critical analysis of the source literature, descriptive and comparative analysis, diagnostic survey as well as simple statistical methods, i.e. analysis of the structure or Kendall’s Tau correlation analysis. The empirical data were collected in May 2022 using the CAWI (computer-assisted web interview) method. The research sample was representative and included 1,000 representatives of Polish population. Main findings: Among the factors determining the adoption decisions of FinTech lenders’ clients, two groups of constructs can be distinguished. The first one consists of classic prerequisites (e.g. perceived ease of use [PEU], perceived usefulness [PU]), identified for a wide range of entities offering financial services based on information technologies. The second group consists of the factors attributed mainly to FinTech lenders, among which the leading position is taken by expressed trust (T) and personal innovativeness (PI). The analyzes carried out in the article confirmed that the expressed trust and personal innovativeness represent the statistically significant factors influencing the decisions made by Poles related to using digital loan services offered by FinTech lenders. The influence of these constructs on the adopted attitudes is a function of their mutual relationship, based on the reciprocal reinforcement of these factors. The conducted research also resulted in developing the economic and demographic profile of a person using the services of FinTech lenders. It is a man, aged 25–34, a university graduate earning an income exceeding PLN 5,000 and residing in a city populated by over 500,000 residents.
Research background: Traditional financial institutions are facing new competitors - FinTech lenders. The development of these entities and their services depends on many factors, including the level of their acceptance and use by potential and/or current customers. This acceptance determines the ability to create desired financial results and defines the set of FinTech lenders' activities and also their environment aimed at shaping the offer which meets their consumers' expectations. The limited number of studies addressing the identification and assessment of the impact exerted by the adoption factors of lending services offered by FinTech lenders and the lack of such analyzes relating to these decisions made by consumers from Central and Eastern Europe argue for the need to conduct such research. Purpose of the article: Identify factors driving consumers' adoption of digital lending services offered by FinTech lenders in Poland. Methods: Critical analysis of the source literature, descriptive and comparative analysis, diagnostic survey, econometric methods (PCA, SEM used in the TAM). Empirical data come from the surveys carried out in May 2022 using the CAWI method and covering a representative sample of 1,000 Poles. Findings & value added: The study identified factors driving consumers' adoption of digital lending services, including perceived trust, risk, usefulness and financial health. It has been proven that the perceived ease of use and innovation do not represent the statistically significant constructs influencing the accepted adoption attitudes. The adopted research model shows a considerable power to explain the intention of using digital loans. The article is the first scientific study of this type discussing the identification of adoption factors for loan services offered by FinTech lenders operating on the Central and Eastern European market. The presented example of Poland being the leader in this dynamically developing market provides the background for conducting international comparative studies in the future.
Technological innovations, the digitization process of financial systems as well as changes in consumer preferences and choices of payment forms have resulted in the emergence of new services, including mobile payments. BLIK system, managed by the company Polski Standard Płatności sp. z o.o. (Polish Payments Standard Ltd.) is one of the organizers and operators of such payments. This FinTech is a dynamically growing leader in the domestic mobile payments market and an important part of the digital transformation experienced by the CEE countries. The author’s review of the source literature demonstrates weakness related to the scientific recognition of problems concerning the identification, analysis and impact assessment of the perceived risks and benefits that constitute the rationale for using BLIK mobile payments by the representatives of generational cohorts of Poles. These problems define the research purpose of this article. The study adopts the research perspective set by the theory of reasoned action (TRA) and the net worth model (NVM), and also uses critical analysis of the source literature, descriptive and comparative analysis, a diagnostic survey and statistical methods, i.e. structure analysis or Kendall’s Tau correlation analysis. Empirical data were collected in 2023 using the CAWI method. They originated from a representative survey sample of 1,000 Poles. The conducted studies confirmed the validity of using TRA theory and NVM model in the process of identifying the adoption factors of innovative payment instruments. They proved that the consumers’ perceptions of risk as well as monetary and non-monetary benefits strongly influence their decisions to use mobile payments, while both this perception and use show differences for the particular generational cohorts of surveyed Poles.
Recent years have seen rapid development in the market of mobile payment services. BLIK system, introduced in 2015 by the Polish Payment Standard represents one of such payment innovations. The data provided by Narodowy Bank Polski indicate that the number of BLIK transactions increased to the level of 1.24 billion by the end of 2022, i.e. during 7 years of the system operation, while their value exceeded PLN 164 billion. In addition, BLIK took the first place in the ranking of solutions allowing A2A (account-to-account) payments in e-commerce transactions offered by the entities from CCE countries. The growing popularity of BLIK system and the results of the authors’ own review of the source literature, confirming the limited number of studies addressing mobile payments made by different groups of their users, who: (a) show diversified preferences in using digital technology and (b) present different attitudes towards adopting digital financial services, in addition to the lack of such analyses covering Polish consumers, prompted the authors to undertake research in this area. Their goal was to assess the impact of perceived benefits and risks on the intentions to continue using BLIK payments, and to identify the importance of these factors in the adoption decisions of early and late adopters. The following research methods were used to achieve the research purpose: critical analysis of the source literature, descriptive and comparative analysis, the theory of reasoned action (TRA), net valence model (NVM), confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) and structural equation model (SEM). The diagnostic survey, covering a representative research sample of 1,000 Poles, was conducted in June 2023 using CAWI technique. The applied research tool was an original authors’ survey questionnaire, whereas the main research hypothesis was: there is a difference in the perception of benefits and risks affecting the intentions to continue using BLIK payments by their early and late adopters. The adopted research model and the related specific hypotheses resulted from using the theoretical framework based on the assumptions of the theory of reasoned action (TRA) and the net valence model (NVM), which was intended by the authors to combine both positive and negative effects of the decision to use BLIK mobile payment services. The study confirmed impact of perceived benefits and risks on consumers’ intentions to continue using BLIK payments, as well as diversified perceptions of these constructs by separate groups of their early and late adopters. The obtained research results provide a better understanding of how technology affects payment behavior of BLIK users, and thus allows formulating practical implications for various stakeholder groups, including retail and service companies or regulatory authorities. A limitation of the original research conducted by the authors is narrowing it down to Polish society, which may not reflect global trends in mobile payments. However, this limitation can be approached as an opportunity to use the findings presented in this paper as an incentive to conduct further research and comparative analyses to identify the influence of cultural factors or payment behaviors specific to different societies. Other suggested research directions include: the identification and analysis of adoption factors conducted from the perspective of entities offering this payment method to their customers, or the importance of new functionalities for the development of BLIK payment system, such as deferred payment service – BNPL (Buy Now, Pay Later).
PL
Celem artykułu jest ocena wpływu postrzeganych korzyści i ryzyka na intencje kontynuacji korzystania z płatności BLIK oraz identyfikacja ich znaczenia w decyzjach adopcyjnych wczesnych i spóźnionych użytkowników. Do jego realizacji wykorzystano: krytyczną analizę literatury przedmiotu, analizę opisową i porównawczą, teorię uzasadnionego działania, model wartościowości netto, konfirmacyjną analizę czynnikową i model równań strukturalnych. Badania obejmujące reprezentatywną próbę składającą się z 1000 Polaków przeprowadzono w czerwcu 2023 r. techniką CAWI. Strukturę artykułu, obok wstępu i zakończenia, tworzą następujące części: Blik na rynku usług płatności mobilnych, uwarunkowania adopcji płatności mobilnych jako obszar badań naukowych, teoria uzasadnionego działania i model wartościowości netto, model badawczy i hipotezy badawcze, metoda badawcza, rezultaty badań, dyskusja. Wyniki badań dowiodły, że postrzegane korzyści i ryzyko wpływają na intencje kontynuacji korzystania z płatności BLIK przez konsumentów oraz że czynniki te mają różne znaczenie dla wczesnych i spóźnionych ich użytkowników.
This article focuses on the fastest-growing consumer credit segment usually associated with e-commerce, but increasingly offered for brick-and-mortar shopping too. The purpose of the study was to identify how, and the extent to which, specific aspects of consumer behaviour – particularly in terms of attitudes towards money management, and socio-demographics – influence the use of BNPL. The reasons are socio-demographic, economic, psychological and technological. The article incorporates a broad literature review of the motives behind consumers' use of BNPL as well as an original empirical survey among a representative sample of Poles, conducted using the CAWI technique. The impact and strength of individual factors for choosing BNPL were identified via a logistic regression model. The statistical significance of the selected variables was then evaluated, followed by the elimination of non-significant variables from the model. It helped select statistically significant factors for using BNPL. Among 7 statistically significant variables, 3 relate to socio-demographic features of the respondents – level of education, income and gender. Personal innovativeness, inclination towards going into debt, as well as a family history of taking various loans slightly increase the probability of opting for BNPL. It had been presumed that propensity to save would have a negative effect, and that optimism would have a positive influence, on choosing BNPL; however, this presumption was not demonstrated. Nor do consumerism and impulsiveness in making purchases affect the likelihood of using BNPL. Of all the statistically significant factors underlying decisions to choose BNPL, the consumer’s use of LendTech has the greatest impact, increasing the chance of using BNPL. This suggests that similar consumers constitute these two segments. LendTech (lending technology) is defined as part of the FinTech (financial technology) sector, which concerns the granting of digital loans by non-bank lending institutions in remote channels (Waliszewski et al, 2024).
Research background: BNPL (Buy Now, Pay Later) is a rapidly growing area of fintech that is changing the way consumers manage their finances and make purchases online. The rationale for undertaking research of the factors underlying the adoption of this payment method is the innovation of the subject matter and the practical importance of the findings for BNPL providers and regulatory institutions. Our research provides a better understanding of consumer needs and behavior, which can lead to more effective marketing strategies and regulatory action to protect consumers, and promote responsible lending and borrowing. In addition, the limited number of investigations on what makes people choose BNPL and the lack of studies relating to the reasons why consumers in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) opt for deferred payments also indicate the need for such research. Purpose of the article: To identify and assess the factors that influence consumers' adoption of BNPL payments in Poland. Methods: Critical analysis of the source literature, Technology Acceptance Model (TAM), Partial Least Square-Structural Equation Modelling (PLS-SEM). Empirical data is from a survey conducted in August 2024 using the CAWI method on a sample of 350 Poles. Findings & value added: The study identifies factors influencing the adoption of BNPL payments by consumers in Poland. These include perceived usefulness (PU), risk (PR), and personal innovation (PI). Perceived trust (PT), however, does not have a statistically significant effect on adoption attitudes (ATT). Similarly, perceived ease of use (PEOU) does not directly influence attitudes (ATT). The paper fills a gap in the literature, as most of the research on BNPL to date has focused on the Anglo-Saxon and Asian markets, while the CEE context has not yet been explored. This is the first research study to present, based on the TAM model, the identification of factors of BNPL adoption by Polish consumers, where the digital payments market is the fastest growing in CEE. Beyond its national relevance, the study offers a new conceptual contribution to global fintech literature by demonstrating how the determinants of BNPL adoption evolve with the digital maturity of a market. Unlike results from Anglo-Saxon and Asian contexts-where perceived ease of use and trust are key drivers-our findings indicate that in post-emerging markets such as Poland, these classical TAM constructs lose explanatory power in favor of perceived usefulness, perceived risk, and personal innovativeness. This maturity-dependent shift in adoption mechanisms can inform cross-country comparisons and theoretical modelling of fintech adoption in diverse economies. Hence, the study provides a transferable analytical framework valuable for international researchers and practitioners seeking to understand how fintech adoption differs between mature, emerging, and developing markets.
The main objective of the article is to identify and evaluate the key determinants of consumer recommendation intention with Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) services, operationalised through the intention to recommend such services to others through the intention to recommend such services to others. The study investigates the influence of five core constructs: perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, perceived trust, and perceived risk. Data are collected from a quota sample of 350 users of deferred payment services, selected in accordance with the demographic profile of BNPL users. The study employs PLS-SEM. The results show that perceived usefulness and perceived trust in the BNPL provider significantly boost recommendation intention. Perceived risk negatively impacts recommendation intention, while perceived ease of use has only a marginal effect. These results contribute to the existing literature by elucidating the behavioural mechanisms underlying BNPL usage and provide actionable insights for financial service providers aiming to enhance consumer recommendation intention and retention.
Research background: According to the World Bank (2020), about 60% of adults in developing countries do not use formal financial services. Furthermore, according to the Polish Association of Loan Institutions (2022), about 3 million Poles use loans, most of them obtained online. Among the reasons for more than a decade of growth of interest in the non-bank consumer lending market there are the development of modern technology applications in finance and the establishment of the Lendtech sector. Purpose of the article: The main goal of the paper is to verify the role played by the Lendtech (LT) sector in the consumer credit market in the context of household financial exclusion. The following research questions were asked: Do credit-excluded households take advantage of LT services and, if so, to what extent? What are the behaviours and preferences of those who use consumer credit offered by LT? Do socio-demographic characteristics determine consumer use of loans offered by LT and, if so, what are they? Is the use of loans offered by LT due to credit exclusion or other factors? What action should be taken by participants in the digital consumer loan market interested in its inclusive direction? Methods: The paper uses the following methods: critical analysis of the literature, Kruskal-Wallis test, Mann-Whitney test, and nonparametric regression algorithm: k-nearest neighbors, as well as inductive inference methods. The data used is primary in nature and comes from a nationwide survey, September 2022 (CAWI method) of 1,200 Poles, of whom 200 respondents are Lendtech customers. The quota selection applied made it possible to reflect characteristics corresponding to the population of customers of lending institutions registered in BIK databases. Findings & value added: The article is a pioneering study based on an independent scientific survey, devoted to the Polish LT services market considered in terms of its relationship with one of the types of financial exclusion: credit exclusion. The most important conclusion is that people at risk of credit exclusion find a financing substitute in the LT sector, and thus it plays an important role in reducing financial exclusion, while maintaining the principle of creditworthiness verification.
Research background: People who take non-banking loans are primarily perceived as excluded from accessing bank services. The growth of e-commerce and the increasing digitalisation of customer interactions with banks was particularly accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic (the first ‘black swan’). These processes have also influenced the rapid growth of the LendTech (LT) sector within FinTech with its digital loans and buy-now-pay-later (BNPL) services. The war in Ukraine (the second ‘black swan’) has led to an energy crisis, increased inflation, interest rates and credit costs, and reduced credit accessibility. In this context, the following research questions are addressed: Are the LT and banking sectors complementary or substitutive in the area of consumer financing? Does complementarity apply to all customer segments and loan amounts? How does the extent of complementarity or substitutability of the LT sector depend on, and to what extent do changes in the regulatory and macroeconomic environment affect, the interaction between the banking and LT sectors? Purpose of the article: The aim of the article is to identify trends in the LT sector within FinTech in the context of assessing the scale and determinants of current and future complementarity of the non-bank sector and the banking sector in the area of consumer credit in time of black swans. An additional purpose of the article is to estimate revenues from the basic operating activities of companies from the on-line channel. Methods: The research process was multi-stage and the research procedure was structured. Due to the lack of a uniform source of data on LT products and services, the study used many data sources - data from the Credit Information Bureau, a primary nationwide survey on LT users a primary survey of people representing LT's managerial staff. The selection of LTs was carried out according to the concept of the monetary sampling unit. The Horvitz-Thompson estimator with Sen‐Yates‐Grundy variance form was used to estimate net operating income for LT from the online channel in 2021. Findings & value added: The LT companies surveyed state that black swans (the COVID-19 pandemic and the war in Ukraine) and the current macroeconomic situation have not significantly affected demand for non-banking loans. The reduction in the opportunities for the LT sector as a result of anti-usury regulations will only lead to a shift in consumer demand to the pawnshop sector and the shadow economy, which will be detrimental to consumers. Complementarity between LT and the banking sector is revealed especially in crisis situations, thus limiting the effects of market shock (limited supply of loans offered by banks). In periods of stabilisation, a rather clear division of preferences is noticeable – in the case of seniors and loans for higher amounts, banks dominate, while in the case of lower amounts and in younger age groups, non-bank institutions are more popular. The mechanism by which shrinking banking services are replaced by LT in short-term crises confirms the importance of LT in balancing the Consumer Finance market in the face of unstable periods. From a medium- and long-term perspective, it should be noted that inflation and rising interest rates will increase the scale of credit exclusion in commercial banks, shifting part of the demand to the non-bank sector. These phenomena have an international dimension. Similar observations were made already in 2012 by the CFPB in the USA and the British FTA, when analysing the consumer finance market immediately after the subprime crisis, emphasising the effects of limiting access to bank consumer loans and the resulting growth of the LT market (Gębski, 2013).
Dynamiczny rozwój sektora FinTech, przyspieszony przez pandemię COVID-19 oraz postępującą cyfryzację usług finansowych, doprowadził do pojawienia się i szybkiej ekspansji płatności odroczonych typu buy now, pay later (BNPL). W dotychczasowych badaniach koncentrowano się głównie na BNPL jako odrębnym instrumencie finansowym, analizując czynniki jego wdrażania, wpływ na zachowania konsumentów, inkluzję finansową oraz wyzwania regulacyjne. Jednocześnie literatura dotycząca kart kredytowych jest rozbudowana, jednak rzadko uwzględnia relacje między kredytem konsumenckim a nowymi formami kredytu cyfrowego. Brakuje pogłębionych analiz empirycznych, które wprost badałyby relację między BNPL a kartami kredytowymi w kategoriach substytucyjności lub komplementarności, zwłaszcza na polskim rynku. Artykuł wypełnia tę lukę badawczą, dostarczając pierwszą, opartą na danych transakcyjnych z Biura Informacji Kredytowej (BIK), analizę dynamiki obu instrumentów oraz ich powiązań z wybranymi zmiennymi makroekonomicznymi. Nowością pracy jest zastosowanie metody Dynamic Time Warping (DTW) do porównania ścieżek czasowych BNPL i kart kredytowych. Główne pytanie badawcze dotyczy tego, czy płatności odroczone BNPL w Polsce pełnią rolę substytutu kart kredytowych czy raczej funkcjonują jako instrument komplementarny, współistniejący z tradycyjnymi formami kredytu konsumenckiego. Autorzy analizują również, czy dynamika wykorzystania obu produktów jest powiązana z czynnikami makroekonomicznymi, takimi jak dochody, nastroje konsumenckie oraz łączna wartość kredytów konsumenckich. Główna hipoteza artykułu zakłada, że usługi BNPL w Polsce obecnie są uzupełnieniem tradycyjnych produktów kredytowych i nie stanowią ich bezpośredniego substytutu. Hipotezy szczegółowe wskazują, że: – użytkownicy BNPL często jednocześnie mają zobowiązania z tytułu kart kredytowych, – nie występują istotne statystycznie dynamiczne korelacje pomiędzy szeregami czasowymi transakcji BNPL i kart kredytowych, – relacja między tymi instrumentami może ewoluować w długim okresie, jednak w analizowanym horyzoncie dominuje komplementarność. Powodem sformułowania hipotez jest obserwowany równoległy wzrost rynku BNPL i stagnacja lub spowolnienie rynku kart kredytowych, co rodzi pytania o przyszłą strukturę rynku kredytu konsumenckiego. Badanie opiera się na dwóch źródłach danych: – badaniu ankietowym CAWI przeprowadzonym wśród 350 aktywnych użytkowników BNPL w Polsce, – miesięcznych danych transakcyjnych BIK obejmujących okres od czerwca 2023 r. do lipca 2025 r. Kluczową metodą analityczną jest DTW, umożliwiająca porównywanie szeregów czasowych o różnej dynamice i potencjalnych opóźnieniach. Metoda ta jest szczególnie przydatna w analizie zjawisk finansowych, w przypadku których reakcje zmiennych mogą być przesunięte w czasie. Uzupełniająco zastosowano analizę klastrową oraz interpretację wyników w świetle literatury przedmiotu. Wyniki analizy DTW nie wykazały wyraźnego podobieństwa trajektorii czasowych liczby i wartości transakcji BNPL oraz kart kredytowych, co sugeruje brak silnych podstaw empirycznych, by stwierdzić ich substytucyjność. Jednocześnie zaobserwowano zbliżone ścieżki czasowe zmiennych makroekonomicznych (dochody, wskaźnik ufności konsumenckiej, skumulowana wartość kredytów konsumenckich), co wskazuje na ich wspólny wpływ na skłonność gospodarstw domowych do zadłużania się. Analiza przesunięć czasowych sugeruje, że wzrost wykorzystania BNPL często jest poprzedzony wzrostem dochodów, podczas gdy reakcja w zakresie kart kredytowych pojawia się z opóźnieniem. Wyniki te wspierają tezę o odmiennych funkcjach obu instrumentów w cyklu konsumpcyjnym. Autorzy wnioskują, że BNPL w Polsce pełni obecnie funkcję komplementarną wobec kart kredytowych, zwiększając elastyczność finansowania konsumpcji i dostęp do krótkoterminowego kredytu, zwłaszcza dla młodszych i mniej zamożnych konsumentów. Wyniki mają istotne implikacje praktyczne dla banków, firm FinTech oraz regulatorów, m.in. w zakresie projektowania produktów, oceny ryzyka kanibalizacji oraz monitorowania zadłużenia gospodarstw domowych. Podstawowym ograniczeniem badania jest krótki horyzont czasowy danych dotyczących BNPL. Wynika to stąd, że dopiero niedawno wprowadzono obowiązek raportowania tych zobowiązań do BIK (od 18 maja 2023 r.). Ponadto analiza koncentruje się na rynku polskim, co ogranicza możliwość bezpośrednich uogólnień międzynarodowych. Autorzy podkreślają również, że relacja między BNPL a kartami kredytowymi może się zmieniać wraz z dojrzewaniem rynku i dalszym rozwojem regulacji.
EN
The rise of buy now, pay later (BNPL) services has disrupted traditional consumer credit markets, raising questions about their relationship with established products such as credit cards. Although both offer short-term financing with similar features – such as interest-free periods and flexible repayment options, their roles in consumer behaviour and financial systems are not yet fully understood. This study addresses this gap by analysing potential correlations and changes in the use of BNPL and credit cards in Poland. The research combines a literature review with empirical analysis based on two data sources: a CAWI survey of 350 BNPL users and transaction-level data from the Credit Information Bureau (BIK) from June 2023 to July 2025. Using Dynamic Time Warping (DTW), the study examines relationships between macroeconomic indicators and transaction values and volumes. Results show no clear similarity in the trends of BNPL and credit card transactions, suggesting they do not evolve in a correlated way. However, salary-related variables, CCI, and CL follow similar patterns over time.Overall, the findings provide a nuanced view of how BNPL and credit cards coexist rather than directly substitute each other in the Polish market.
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.