A book review of the Polish translation of The Quality of Mercy: Reflections on Shakespeare by Peter Brook. The reviewer thoroughly, chapter after chapter, follows the director’s argument, analysing his reflexions. He emphasises the key questions and problems posed by Brook, who has grappled with Shakespeare’s work and confronted it with real life, the political and social reality, and most of all, with theatrical practice for the last seventy years. The conclusions reached by the author by the end of the book, as brilliant and amazing as they are in their profoundness and simplicity, serve Arkadiusz Rogoziński as a starting point for his own doubts and questions. The review ends with the questions that open up room for further discussion: Is it possible for the theatre of the Christian world to have some other meaning than that invented by the ancient Greeks? Will freedom, mercy, and quality-the Shakespearean terms analysed by Brook in detail-ever be able to replace pity and fear?
PL
Tekst stanowi recenzję najnowszej książki Petera Brooka wydanej w języku polskim Wolność i łaska: Rozważania o Szekspirze (The Quality of Mercy: Reflections on Shakespeare). Autor recenzji skrupulatnie i chwilami wnikliwie, rozdział po rozdziale, podąża za reżyserem, analizując jego refleksje. Akcentuje kluczowe pytania i problemy stawiane przez Brooka, który przez siedemdziesiąt lat prowadził twórczy dialog z dziełem Stratfordczyka, konfrontował je z życiem, rzeczywistością polityczną i społeczną, a przede wszystkim z praktyką teatralną. Wnioski, którymi angielski reżyser wieńczy książkę – zdumiewające i olśniewające zarazem swoją prostotą i głębią, stanowią dla recenzenta punkt wyjścia do sformułowania własnych wątpliwości i postawienia samodzielnych już pytań. Recenzję wieńczą pytania, otwierające obszar dla pogłębionej dyskusji: Czy w chrześcijańskim świecie teatr może mieć inne przeznaczenie niż to, które wymyślili dla niego starożytni Grecy? Czy wolność, łaska i quality [terminy Szekspirowkie szczegółowo analizowane przez Brooka] mogłyby kiedyś zastąpić litość i trwogę?
This article deals with retranslation practice on the example of Polish Shakespeare translations in the 20th and 21st century. The aim of the article is (1) to define retranslation in the context of centuries-long, intense critical and theatrical reception of European canonical drama, (2) to discuss the profile of Polish Shakespeare translations in the 20th and 21st century, particularly with regards to (re) translation strategies and modes of promotion/dissemination of translations in the target culture, (3) to account for the co-existence of numerous retranslations given the strong diversification of patronage and the growing importance of digital resources. Special attention is given to the specificity of retranslation practice when Shakespeare’s plays are fully assimilated into Polish literary and theatrical culture, the retranslation dynamics depends on theatrical and ideological factors, and translators combine retranslation with their own literary agendas. The article concludes with a discussion of the impact of digital resources on translation canonicity and possible decline of logocentric drama translation theories.
PL
Artykuł poświęcony jest praktyce retranslacji w odniesieniu do polskich przekładów dramatów Williama Shakespeare’a w XX i XXI wieku. Jego celem jest: 1) próba zdefiniowania retranslacji w warunkach wielowiekowej recepcji dramatów z kanonu europejskiego, charakteryzujących się intensywną recepcją teatralną i krytyczną; 2) przegląd polskich zasobów tłumaczeń Shakespeare’a w XX i XXI wieku, z uwzględnieniem strategii (re)translacji oraz specyfiki promocji/upowszechniania retranslacji w docelowej przestrzeni kulturowej; 3) refleksja nad współistnieniem przekładów Shakespeare’a w warunkach rozproszonego mecenatu, z rosnącym znaczeniem zasobów cyfrowych. W szczególny sposób rozpatrywana jest kwestia wyodrębnienia się praktyki retranslacji w warunkach pełnej asymilacji dramaturgii Shakespeare’a w polskiej kulturze literackiej i teatralnej, uzależnienie dynamiki retranslacji od uwarunkowań teatralnych i ideologicznych, a także powiązań retranslacji dramatu z twórczością własną tłumaczy. Konkluzję artykułu stanowią uwagi o wpływie zasobów cyfrowych na wyznaczniki kanoniczności przekładów, a także o potencjalnym schyłku logocentrycznych doktryn przekładowych.
The paper discusses major problems and issues of translating law and legal language into Polish as illustrated by selected examples from William Shakespeare’s three plays: King Lear, The Merchant of Venice and Measure for Measure. The common feature of the plays is the context of the court and the trial. In King Lear, Shakespeare depicts a mock-trial of the main character’s two daughters, Regan and Goneril. The crux of The Merchant of Venice is the proceedings instigated by Shylock against his debtor, Antonio. Measure for Measure features a summary trial of two local rogues, Froth and Pompey, who are brought to justice by the constable Elbow. A comparison of the English original law-embedded scenes with their Polish counterparts shows that Polish translators approached Shakespeare’s legal lexicon differently. They frequently neutralised legal language or offered the equivalents that do not overlap with the source text. The different treatment of legal language by the translators results in various readings and interpretations of the original. The paper also provides a commentary on the basic concepts and institutions of English law in Shakespeare’s analysed plays.
The article investigates the canonical plays of William Shakespeare - Hamlet, Macbeth, A Midsummer Night’s Dream and The Tempest - in an attempt to determine the nature of Shakespeare’s position on the early modern tendency to demonize fairy belief and to view fairies as merely a form of demonic manifestation. Fairy belief left its mark on all four plays, to a greater or lesser extent, and intertwined with the religious concerns of the period, it provides an important perspective on the problem of religion in Shakespeare’s works. The article will attempt to establish whether Shakespeare subscribed to the tendency of viewing fairies as demonic agents, as epitomized by the Daemonologie of King James, or opposed it. Special emphasis will also be put on the conflation of fairies and Catholicism that one finds best exemplified in Thomas Hobbes’ Leviathan. The article draws on a wealth of recent scholarship on early modern fairies, bringing together historical reflection on the changing perception of the fairy figure, research into Shakespeare’s attitude towards Catholicism and analyses of the many facets of anti-Catholic polemic emerging from early modern Protestant discourse.
The article investigates the canonical plays of William Shakespeare - Hamlet, Macbeth, A Midsummer Night’s Dream and The Tempest - in an attempt to determine the nature of Shakespeare’s position on the early modern tendency to demonize fairy belief and to view fairies as merely a form of demonic manifestation. Fairy belief left its mark on all four plays, to a greater or lesser extent, and intertwined with the religious concerns of the period, it provides an important perspective on the problem of religion in Shakespeare’s works. The article will attempt to establish whether Shakespeare subscribed to the tendency of viewing fairies as demonic agents, as epitomized by the Daemonologie of King James, or opposed it. Special emphasis will also be put on the conflation of fairies and Catholicism that one finds best exemplified in Thomas Hobbes’ Leviathan. The article draws on a wealth of recent scholarship on early modern fairies, bringing together historical reflection on the changing perception of the fairy figure, research into Shakespeare’s attitude towards Catholicism and analyses of the many facets of anti-Catholic polemic emerging from early modern Protestant discourse.
As an innovative dramatist, Gombrowicz, strangely, expresses little interest in avant-garde theatre and drama of his epoch. More often, though, he refers to traditional form of performance and world classics, especially to Shakespeare's dramas which he exploits to replicate in the theatre Shakespearian gesture and his brilliancy. To achieve that Gombrowicz quotes or cryptoquotes Shakespeare, imitates the form and construction of his works, taking advantage of the overlap of home drama structures and the drama of power, generation gap, the technique of “theatre in theatre,” and ultimately the fundamental moral and metaphysical questions. Gombrowicz's concept of man as an eternal player is also adopted from Shakespeare. What mediates between Gombrowicz and Shakespeare's plays is Polish romantic drama, especially “Balladyna”, seen as “Macbeth” motifs replica, and 19th c. middle-class drama. In this way Gombrowicz brings Shakespearian issues closer to our times and to modern concept of man in order to once again pose the same great philosophical questions.
The Polski Theatre has presented Shakespeare’s Hamlet to its audiences three times so far, in 1922, 1939, and 1947. The production of 1922, directed by the theatre manager Arnold Szyfman, constituted a decisive element of the counteroffensive mounted against increasingly heavy attacks of the critics. They all accused the theatre of lowering its artistic level. The Shakespearean counterstroke was received warmly, in hopes of change for the better. Unexpectedly, the premiere of Hamlet directed by Aleksander Węgierko, which took place on 4 April 1939, was overshadowed by political life, as the threat of war was looming ever larger and Great Britain had just provided Poland with the guarantees of military help. Thus, contrary to the producers’ intentions, many reviewers interpreted the play, and Fortinbras’ army march against Poland especially, in the context of the current political situation. As a result, the artistic qualities were often overlooked. Another premiere of Hamlet, on 17 July 1947, again directed by Szyfman, inaugurated the final of the all-national Shakespearean Competition, which was to show the condition of theatre companies in post-war Poland. The Competition was taking place in a tragically ambiguous situation. On the one hand, it was supposed to be a sign of Polish ties with European culture while on the other hand, it was organised in a country being, for all practical purposes, under Soviet occupation, in the circumstances of increasing Communist terror. This time, however, due to censorship, the theatre reviews were devoid of clear political references. The production received positive but not enthusiastic reviews even though it won the greatest number of awards in the competition. Tadeusz Kończyc, one of the 1939 reviewers, remarked that, despite difficulties, the greatest theatres once in a while “come back to Hamlet as to a fount of powerful and everlasting impressions”. The Polski Theatre in Warsaw has not done so for 66 years.
The author proposes a dialogic reading of Włodzimierz Szturc’s book Diapazony i fonosfery [Diapasons and Phonospheres] (Kraków 2020), interlinking its motifs with Shakespeare’s The Tempest, as well as with the philosophical reflection of Polish Romantic author Juliusz Słowacki and the poetry of Paul Celan. His main focus is the meeting of spirit and matter in the acoustic matter of words. The author points out that this interpretation allows texts to resound, to resonate, creating meanings which, if not different from those effected by semantics, in any case substantially mediate them. He stresses that Szturc’s hermeneutics emphasizes listening, and especially the duty of silently listening out for the world. If this duty is disregarded, one speaks forcing others to silence. The author considers this as a fundamental mechanism – not only hermeneutical, but also political. Using the example of Shakespeare’s texts, he argues that one who fails to hear a voice other than his own will sooner or later bring himself and the world to the edge of an abyss.
This article discusses experimental translation on the example of intralingual translation in the Play On! Translation project accompanying the Oregon Shakespeare Festival, and intersemotic/intermedial translation in the OMGShakespeare series and Star Trek-related texts. These are approached as exercises in post-translation as defined by Edwin Gentzler in his volume on the subject.
The article takes up the theme of Agamben’s violence without a form of justice and reads Shakespeare’s tragedy as spanned between Cordelia’s “nothing” at the start of the play and Lear’s “never” at its end. It also approaches a question of the relationship between, in Rousseau’s word, “l’homme naturel” and “citoyen.” Lear’s push towards a position of being “unaccommodated” suggests a move away from the organization of life previously holding its rule over men towards a marginal, peripheral zone with uncertain rules where man has to risk his own decisions rather than merely follow the custom.
Hamlet has been frequently performed on the Czech stage, not only during the nineteenth century but also throughout the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. From 1905 until the end of his career at the National Theatre in Prague, Hamlet was also the mainstay of Jaroslav Kvapil’s repertoire. The aim of this paper is to concentrate on four productions of Hamlet at the National theatre in Prague in 1905, 1915, 1916, and 1920. In order to illustrate the critical reception of these four productions, the paper draws upon a range of period theatre reviews and critical commentaries. It attempts to show how directorial and acting choices have shaped the play in performance, by focusing in particular on Eduard Vojan’s renditions of Hamlet, set in different national contexts. Vojan (1853–1920) was one of the greatest Czech actors and performers of Shakespearean protagonists, famous for his deep, almost Protean insight into his characters. His portrayal of Hamlet (1905) still represents one of the best Shakespearean renditions on the Czech stage. Vojan discovered and skilfully interpreted Hamlet’s complicated character. His Danish prince was a lonely, sarcastic, and nonconforming individual opposing the world’s pettiness.
The author argues that although William Shakespeare sometimes allows for minor inconsistencies in his plays, which more often than not pass unnoticed during their performances, he meticulously weaves their structures. In the course of analysing two examples of the playwright’s works, The Comedy of Errors and Much Ado About Nothing, the author suggests that in the former the Bard offers an hour-after-hour image of the fictional reality, whereas in the latter he not only provides us with a detailed account of the events placed within the calendar, but also seems to take advantage of this structure to suggest some hidden meaning.
The paper sets to explore the specificity of the Slavic translations of Shakespeare with some special emphasis on the prosodic features of Slavic languages. Preceded by a general discussion of the sounds and rhythms of Slavic languages, the paper presents the historical overview of the translations strategies used by translators to deal with the challenges of Shakespeare’s iambic pentameter. Here some of the most important shaping factors are discussed such as the pressure of the Neoclassical and Romantic models or the influence of Schlegel’s doctrine of organic poetry. Secondly, the paper accounts for the establishment of the national canons of Shakespeare’s translations and their impact on the subsequent attempts at translation.
The author draws attention to the fact that in William Shakespeare’s plays characters tell their stories and tales with varying degrees of credibility. In his paper he makes an attempt to reconstruct the actual circumstances of both the storm and shipwreck in The Tempest by analysing all the relevant accounts in the play. While investigating the reliability of the characters’ narratives, the author suggests that Ariel is a spirit whose report of the raised tempest and subsequent shipwreck is partly a trustworthy account and partly a fictitious and misleading tale, which is demonstrated in the course of comparing his words with the other characters’ assertions of what happened in the initial storm.
Drawing on its author’s Czech translation of nearly seventy poems from Shakespeare’s sonnet cycle, which lies at the very crux of the European literary canon, this paper shares a few insights into the workshop of a classical poetry translator. It explores the phonetic, structural, semantic and imaginative complexities of the most frequently translated sonnet sequence, and shows, step by step, the way a translator has to deal with the various features of Shakespeare’s poems if one’s translation is not to lose its poetry. Thus, the translator’s decision making process is discussed here, showing multiple examples of how the Czech rendering of Shakespeare’s individual lines have evolved to form a quatrain, a couplet, or, as in the case of sonnet 64, the complete poem. In a broader sense, the paper argues against the popular remark by Robert Frost that “poetry is what gets lost in translation”.
The Artists’ Society (Umělecká beseda) fundamentally influenced the artistic life in the Czech lands during the 1860s. It organized writers, artists and musicians and was able to direct their individual work towards a collective goal. Although a number of notable events were held, the music branch was constantly criticised by other branches for its passivity. Despite unforgettable realisations (e.g. Shakespearean festival in 1864, performance of Liszt’s oratorio Saint Elizabeth) it seems that the music branch was in a state of permanent crisis until the early 1870s, out of which it was guided by Otakar Hostinský, Zdeněk Fibich, and later by Antonín Dvořák. The study analyses in detail the process of how the artists gradually found out how to fulfil their artistic goals while keeping in mind economic profit. Spectacular performances of oratorios or efforts to introduce a series of subscription concerts entered history as extraordinary achievements of Bedřich Smetana, Ludevít Procházka, and other prominent members, but financially they exhausted the society. It was only thanks to the intervention of the literary and artistic department that a correction was made, and it was mainly Ludevít Procházka from the music department who found a way that balanced the purely artistic consideration with the requirements of a lossless economy.
CS
Umělecká beseda zásadním způsobem ovlivňovala umělecký život české společnosti šedesátých let 19. století. Organizovala literáty, výtvarníky a hudebníky a jejich individuální tvorbu dokázala nasměrovat ke společnému cíli. Ačkoliv se podařilo uskutečnit řadu pozoruhodných akcí, byl hudební odbor ze strany ostatní odborů neustále kritizován pro svou nečinnost. Přes nezapomenutelné počiny (např. Shakespearovská slavnost roku 1864, provedení Lisztova oratoria Svatá Alžběta roku 1866) se zdá, že hudební odbor byl až do počátku sedmdesátých let ve stavu krize, ze které byl vyveden až organizační činností Otakara Hostinského, Zdeňka Fibicha a později i Antonína Dvořáka. Studie zevrubně analyzuje proces, jak umělci postupně zjišťovali, jak naplnit umělecké cíle a zároveň dbát na ekonomický profit. Velkolepá představení oratorií nebo snahy o zavedení cyklu abonentních koncertů sice vstoupily do historie jako mimořádné počiny Bedřicha Smetany, Ludevíta Procházky a dalších významných členů, ovšem finančně spolek vyčerpávaly. Až díky zásahu literárního a výtvarného odboru došlo k nápravě a z řad hudebního odboru to byl zejména Ludevít Procházka, který našel cestu, jež vyvažovala zřetel ryze umělecký s požadavky na neztrátové hospodaření.
"Wieczór Trzech Króli" ukazuje osobiste relacje miłosne oraz hulanki biesiadników jako zjawiska wprowadzające nieład. Współczesne inscenizacje zazwyczaj prezentują tekst Shakespeare’a jako komedię romantyczną, w której tymczasowe zakłócenie harmonii osobistej i społecznej zostaje ostatecznie przezwyciężone dzięki perspektywie połączenia trzech par węzłami małżeńskimi. Bogatszą i bardziej złożoną interpretację "Wieczoru Trzech Króli" umożliwia analiza pierwszego odnotowanego wystawienia w kolegium prawniczym Middle Temple w 1602. Autor przygląda mu się sięgając po wypracowaną na gruncie neuronauki kognitywnej hipotezę poznania ucieleśnionego, według której procesy poznawcze opierają się na wzajemnym oddziaływaniu ciała ludzkiego i jego środowiska fizycznego oraz społecznego, a pojęcia powstają w wyniku impulsów z układu nerwowego narządów zmysłów i ruchu. W tym ujęciu znaczenie "Wieczoru Trzech Króli" tworzą podczas przedstawienia nie tylko wypowiadane ze sceny kwestie, lecz także biologia, doświadczenia i wartości aktorów i widzów. Wyobrażenie sobie tej inscenizacji w fizycznej przestrzeni i kontekście społecznym Middle Temple pozwala zobaczyć, w jaki sposób trupa Shakespeare’a poruszała złożone kwestie moralne przed publicznością prawników, których decyzje kształtowały porządek społeczny Anglii początku XVII wieku.
EN
"Twelfth Night" presents both personal love and festive reveling as phenomena that create disorder. Contemporary productions often render the play as a romantic comedy in which a temporary disruption of personal and social harmony is finally resolved by the prospect of three marriages. A richer and more complex appreciation of the play can be gained by exploring its first recorded performance at the Middle Temple (a law college) in 1602. I do this through the lens of embodied cognition, a hypothesis arising from cognitive neuroscience which holds that cognition is grounded in bodily interactions with the physical and social environment, and that mental concepts arise from the body’s sensory and motor neural systems. Thus the meaning of "Twelfth Night" in performance is comprised not only of the script’s dialogue, but also the biology, experiences, and values of its performers and audience members. Envisioning the play’s performance in the physical space and social context of the Middle Temple highlights ways in which Shakespeare’s company raised moral complexities for audience members whose legal decisions shaped the order of early modern English society.
The author proposes a dialogic reading of Włodzimierz Szturc’s book Diapazony i fonosfery [Diapasons and Phonospheres] (Kraków 2020), interlinking its motifs with Shakespeare’s The Tempest, as well as with the philosophical reflection of Polish Romantic author Juliusz Słowacki and the poetry of Paul Celan. His main focus is the meeting of spirit and matter in the acoustic matter of words. The author points out that this interpretation allows texts to resound, to resonate, creating meanings which, if not different from those effected by semantics, in any case substantially mediate them. He stresses that Szturc’s hermeneutics emphasizes listening, and especially the duty of silently listening out for the world. If this duty is disregarded, one speaks forcing others to silence. The author considers this as a fundamental mechanism – not only hermeneutical, but also political. Using the example of Shakespeare’s texts, he argues that one who fails to hear a voice other than his own will sooner or later bring himself and the world to the edge of an abyss.
PL
Autor podejmuje próbę dialogicznej lektury książki Włodzimierza Szturca Diapazony i fonosfery (Kraków 2020), krzyżując jej wątki z Szekspirowską Burzą, a także z myślą Słowackiego czy poezją Celana. Interesuje go przede wszystkim spotkanie ducha i materii w dźwiękowej materii słów. Zwraca uwagę, że dzięki takiej interpretacji teksty zaczynają rozbrzmiewać, rezonować, tworząc znaczenia, jeśli nie odmienne od tych kreowanych przez semantykę, to w każdym razie poważnie je moderujące. Podkreśla, że hermeneutyka Szturca kładzie nacisk na słuchanie, zwłaszcza zaś na obowiązek milczącego nasłuchiwania świata. Nie wypełniając tego obowiązku, człowiek mówi, zmuszając innych do milczenia. Autor widzi w tym fundamentalny mechanizm nie tylko hermeneutyczny, ale też polityczny. Na przykładzie tekstów Shakespeare’a dowodzi, że kto nie słyszy głosu innego niż własny, wcześniej czy później doprowadzi siebie i świat na krawędź przepaści.
The article discusses experimental translation on the example of intralingual translation in Play On! Translation project accompanying the Oregon Shakespeare Festival and intersemotic/intermedial translation in OMGShakespeare series and Star Trek-related texts. These are approached as exercises in post-translation as defined by Edwin Gentzler in his volume on the subject.
Working on the role –Richard III The author describes the contexts for working on the title role of Shakespeares Richard III. He points to specific stages in working on the role: familiarising oneself with the original text and associated literature (research), creating the character (concealing intentions, plans and emotions from other characters in the play, the characters internal struggle, perceiving psychological truths); developing relationships with the director and other actors; the use of scenography, costumes, lighting and music to create characters for the stage, considering the meaning of translation and rapport with the audience.
PL
Working on the role –Richard III The author describes the contexts for working on the title role of Shakespeares Richard III. He points to specific stages in working on the role: familiarising oneself with the original text and associated literature (research), creating the character (concealing intentions, plans and emotions from other characters in the play, the characters internal struggle, perceiving psychological truths); developingrelationships with the director and other actors; the use of scenography, costumes, lighting and music to create characters for the stage, considering the meaning of translation and rapport with the audience.
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.