The paper examines the compliance of the regulation of the Minister of Finance of 22 March 2002 on the excise duty, regulation of the Minister of Finance of 23 December 2003 on excise duty and the regulation of the Minister of Finance of 22 April 2004 on the reduction of excise duty with Article 51 (1) and (4) of the Constitution. All of these regulations foresee the possibility to benefit from reduced rates of excise duty on the purchase of heating oils for heating purposes, provided that the seller receives from the buyer, who is a natural person, a statement that the goods are intended for heating purposes. In these statements a number of personal details is required. However, the Article 51 (1) of the Constitution establishes the principle that persons may be required to disclose information about themselves only on the basis of the statute and the Article 51 ( 5) of the Constitution stipulates that the rules and procedures for collection and sharing of information are specified by a statute. Thus, the analysis of the Constitution leads to the conclusion that the provisions of the regulations are inconsistent with the provisions of the Constitution.
The tax liability and the tax obligation are concepts of both the legal and judicial languages. They are frequently considered synonyms to the term tax legal relation. The subject matter of the article is to analyse the meaning they had in the 1934 Tax Ordinance Act. Particularly the author will attempt to reconstruct the meaning of these terms and consequently to determine, whether there are any grounds to determine, that these terms were used as synonyms of the term legal tax relation.
According to article 107 (1) of the Treaty "any aid granted by a Member State or through State resources in any form whatsoever which distorts or threatens to distort competition by favouring certain undertakings or the production of certain goods shall, in so far as it affects trade between Member States, be incompatible with the common market". To be termed aid, a measure must satisfy the four criteria set out in the article. One of them is the selectivity criterion. The Author concentrates on the selectivity issue. He analyzes if the selectivity criterion is satisfied if a reduction of a tax burden does not extend to the entire territory of a Member State also in the case where that reduction is introduced by devolved or autonomous regions which apply throughout their jurisdiction and are not sectorally specific. Author claims that differentiation of the tax burden in a defined geographic area of a Member State may be the result of three types of events. First, it can be result of the autonomous and unilateral decision of the central government of a Member State. Such a measure is clearly selective, as taken by a single body applying only to part of the geographical territory within its competence. It may be also the result of the local authorities decision who have the autonomous power to set for example the tax rate or the tax relief for their geographical jurisdiction. Measures taken by a local authority pursuant to these powers that apply generally throughout its jurisdiction are not selective within the meaning of Article 107 (1) Treaty – even if one authority adopts lower tax rates than all the rest, provided that all local authorities at a particular level (regions, districts or others) have the same kind of power. Finally, a tax burden lower than the national tax burden, decided upon by a local authority and applicable only within the territory of that local authority does not constitute State aid within the mining of Article 107 (1) Treaty if that local authority is institutionally, procedurally and economically autonomous from the central government of the Member State.
The subject of this article is an analysis of the judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union in case C-235/21. The judgment states that, in certain situations, a contractual agreement concluded between two parties may be considered to be an invoice within the meaning of Art. 203 of Council Directive 2006/112/EC of 28 November 2006 on the common system of value added tax. The author attempts to identify the specific requirements that a contractual agreement must meet in order to be recognized as an invoice. In the light of the analysis carried out, such a contractual agreement can be recognized as an invoice if it clearly indicates that the taxable transaction has been carried out. This criterion can only be met by a contract relating to the transfer of ownership of the goods. It must also show that both parties are taxable persons acting as such, and it must specify the amount of tax and the tax rate. The latter may be derived indirectly. Finally, even if the contract meets the abovementioned conditions, it will not be considered an invoice if the supplier of the goods issues an invoice after the conclusion of the contract.
PL
Przedmiotem artykułu jest analiza wyroku Trybunału Sprawiedliwości Unii Europejskiej w sprawie C-235/21. W wyroku tym orzeczono, że w pewnych sytuacjach zawarta umowa może zostać uznana za fakturę w rozumieniu art. 203 dyrektywy Rady 2006/112/WE z 28.11.2006 r. w sprawie wspólnego systemu podatku od wartości dodanej. Autor stara się określić, jakie konkretne cechy musi mieć taka umowa, by mogła zostać uznana za fakturę. W świetle przeprowadzonej analizy za fakturę może zostać uznana umowa, z której wynika, że została dokonana czynność podlegająca opodatkowaniu, to zaś kryterium może spełnić jedynie umowa dotycząca przeniesienia własności rzeczy. Musi z niej również wynikać, że obie jej strony są podatnikami podatku od wartości dodanej, a ponadto musi ona określać kwotę podatku oraz stawkę podatku. Przy tym ta ostatnia może zostać wywiedziona z umowy w sposób pośredni. W końcu, nawet jeśli umowa spełnia powyższe warunki, nie będzie można jej uznać za fakturę, jeśli po jej zawarciu dostawca towaru wystawi fakturę.
Commentary analysed abovementioned judgement of Supreme Administrative Court which deals with a problem of the effectiveness of delivering to the taxpayer information on the suspension of the limitation period for tax payment as a result of initiation criminal proceedings in connection with the suspicion of committing a crime or a penal fiscal offence. The authors are critical of the arguments used by the court in justifying the judgment.
PL
W glosie przeanalizowano uchwałę Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego, która dotyczy problematyki skuteczności doręczenia podatnikowi informacji o zawieszeniu biegu przedawnienia zobowiązania podatkowego na skutek wszczęcia postępowania karnego w związku z podejrzeniem popełnienia przestępstwa lub wykroczenia skarbowego, w sytuacji gdy popełnienie przestępstwa lub wykroczenia wiąże się z niewykonaniem tego zobowiązania. Autorzy krytycznie odnoszą się do argumentacji użytej przez sąd w uzasadnieniu uchwały.
The concept of legal relationship is a tool that lawyers use to describe the legal situation in which entities find themselves due to applicable legal norms. It is therefore a tool for practical analysis of legal norms. The concept of a legal relationship and other legal concepts related to it are used by a lawyer to determine what rights and obligations a particular entity has in a given legal system in relation to the situation of another entity. In other words, it serves to describe the interdependence of the legal situation of entities due to applicable legal norms. Analysis of the legal relationship and related concepts are also useful for researching the behavior of some entities towards others due to applicable legal norms. The concept of legal relationship and the concepts associated with it are therefore a tool for analyzing law in action, thanks to which it is possible to solve a number of legal problems arising in the practice of applying law. It is important for those branches of law in which there are correlations between legal situations of entities of these branches of law. Therefore, it is also important for the tax law and tax research, in which there are relations between the state and taxpayers and other entities of tax law. Although from the most general point of view the structure of the legal relationship may seem to be very similar, however, legal relations in particular branches of law have their own characteristics. This diversity results from the fact that the content of elements determining specific legal relations in these branches of law is different, such as: the subject of the law, facts causing the creation and termination of the legal relationship as well as the content of the rights and obligations of the parties to this relationship. Research on these elements of the legal relationship allows to achieve specific theoretical and practical goals. Due to the fact that they are embedded in applicable law, they allow to build a model of legal relationship, which becomes a tool for practical analysis of applicable law. Secondly, their study allows to deepen knowledge of the characteristics of individual elements of this relationship, such as the subjects of this right. Thanks to this, it is possible to decide what features an entity should have to be able to become the owner of the rights or obligations of a given branch of law, including tax law. The structure of subjectivity in this branch of law is significantly different from the legal subjectivity of civil law. They also allow to catch the relationships between individual rights and individual rights and obligations regulated in a given branch of law. Finally, they allow to understand the premises that give rise to the rights and obligations incumbent on the subjects of a given branch of law. This in turn allows for an in-depth analysis of the tax law norms themselves, as well as views on individual institutions of this law and their critical analysis, as well as a critical analysis of the views of case law on these legal institutions. In the field of tax law science of various countries, models of a tax law relationship have been already created, which allow ordering and analysis of tax law norms. However, many other countries as the Polish tax law science did not pay much attention to this issue of tax law. Therefore, in many countries the most general model of tax law relationship created by the theory of law is used. The same has happened in Polish tax law science. However, this is an insufficient model, as it requires taking into account the state of tax legislation and the specifics of its regulations. Hence, considerations of tax law doctrine’s sometimes lack consistency due to the lack of an appropriate research tool in the form of a tax law relationship model. They also often conflict with each other, because the starting points for the analyses are different. Therefore, further research on tax law relationship is necessary in this field. This paper presents the assumptions concerning scientific research on developing the concept of a tax law relationship.
In this article, the authors analyse the concept of the tax liability of persons deducting income tax payments on account. The authors noted that the paying agent performs his own obligation to collect, or withhold, an amount of money from a person who is not a taxable person and to transfer that amount to the relevant tax authority. This obligation arises as a result of the occurrence of an event described in a statutory provision that imposes an obligation on the paying agent. Under the Tax Ordinance Act the paying agent is liable for his failure to withhold a tax payment or to transfer the tax withheld to the relevant tax authority, but in the opinion of the authors' the applicability of this provision to the paying agent deducting income tax payments on account after a fiscal year end is limited. The authors present the view that adjudicating on the tax liability of paying agents deducting income tax payments on account after a fiscal year end is possible only in the event that the amount paid by the taxpayer is lower than the amount of the tax due, and this understatement results from the fact that the paying agent does not take steps to collect the payments on account and transfer them to the account of the tax authority.
PL
W niniejszym artykule autorzy analizują pojęcie odpowiedzialności płatników zobowiązanych do zapłaty zaliczek na podatek dochodowy. Prezentują stanowisko, zgodnie z którym płatnik realizuje własny obowiązek pobrania lub potrącenia kwoty zaliczki na podatek od osoby w istocie niebędącej podatnikiem i przekazania tej kwoty właściwemu organowi podatkowemu. Obowiązek ten powstaje w wyniku zaistnienia zdarzenia opisanego w przepisie ustawowym, nakładającego obowiązek na płatnika zaliczki na podatek. Zgodnie z przepisami Ordynacji podatkowej płatnik ponosi odpowiedzialność za to, że nie pobrał podatku lub nie przekazał potrąconego podatku właściwemu organowi podatkowemu, ale zdaniem autorów zastosowanie tego przepisu do płatnika pobierającego zaliczki na podatek dochodowy po zakończeniu roku podatkowego jest ograniczone. Autorzy stoją na stanowisku, że orzekanie o odpowiedzialności płatników pobierających zaliczkę na podatek dochodowy po zakończeniu roku podatkowego jest możliwe tylko w przypadku, gdy wpłacona przez podatnika kwota jest niższa niż kwota należnego podatku, zaś owo zaniżenie wynika z niepodjęcia przez płatnika czynności polegających na pobraniu należnych zaliczek i wpłaceniu ich na rachunek organu podatkowego.
Under Polish law a seller of heating oil is required to obtain the declaration of a buyer that the heating oil would be used for heating purposes. Otherwise, the seller cannot apply an excise duty rate applicable to the heating oil, which is significantly lower than a rate applicable to the oil used as motor fuel. The authors of this article have analyzed the consequences of irregularities in these declarations for the sellers from the perspective of Polish and EU law.
The concept of legal relationship is a tool that lawyers use to describe the legal situation in which entities find themselves due to applicable legal norms. It is therefore a tool for practical analysis of legal norms. The concept of a legal relationship and other legal concepts related to it are used by a lawyer to determine what rights and obligations a particular entity has in a given legal system in relation to the situation of another entity. In other words, it serves to describe the interdependence of the legal situation of entities due to applicable legal norms. Analysis of the legal relationship and related concepts are also useful for researching the behavior of some entities towards others due to applicable legal norms. The concept of legal relationship and the concepts associated with it are therefore a tool for analyzing law in action, thanks to which it is possible to solve a number of legal problems arising in the practice of applying law. It is important for those branches of law in which there are correlations between legal situations of entities of these branches of law. Therefore, it is also important for the tax law and tax research, in which there are relations between the state and taxpayers and other entities of tax law. Although from the most general point of view the structure of the legal relationship may seem to be very similar, however, legal relations in particular branches of law have their own characteristics. This diversity results from the fact that the content of elements determining specific legal relations in these branches of law is different, such as: the subject of the law, facts causing the creation and termination of the legal relationship as well as the content of the rights and obligations of the parties to this relationship. Research on these elements of the legal relationship allows to achieve specific theoretical and practical goals. Due to the fact that they are embedded in applicable law, they allow to build a model of legal relationship, which becomes a tool for practical analysis of applicable law. Secondly, their study allows to deepen knowledge of the characteristics of individual elements of this relationship, such as the subjects of this right. Thanks to this, it is possible to decide what features an entity should have to be able to become the owner of the rights or obligations of a given branch of law, including tax law. The structure of subjectivity in this branch of law is significantly different from the legal subjectivity of civil law. They also allow to catch the relationships between individual rights and individual rights and obligations regulated in a given branch of law. Finally, they allow to understand the premises that give rise to the rights and obligations incumbent on the subjects of a given branch of law. This in turn allows for an in-depth analysis of the tax law norms themselves, as well as views on individual institutions of this law and their critical analysis, as well as a critical analysis of the views of case law on these legal institutions. In the field of tax law science of various countries, models of a tax law relationship have been already created, which allow ordering and analysis of tax law norms. However, many other countries as the Polish tax law science did not pay much attention to this issue of tax law. Therefore, in many countries the most general model of tax law relationship created by the theory of law is used. The same has happened in Polish tax law science. However, this is an insufficient model, as it requires taking into account the state of tax legislation and the specifics of its regulations. Hence, considerations of tax law doctrine’s sometimes lack consistency due to the lack of an appropriate research tool in the form of a tax law relationship model. They also often conflict with each other, because the starting points for the analyses are different. Therefore, further research on tax law relationship is necessary in this field. This paper presents the assumptions concerning scientific research on developing the concept of a tax law relationship.
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.