Two different approaches were implemented to aid the process of selecting the best variant of road construction, namely approach based on the outranking relation and verbal decision analysis. Out of wide range of outranking methods three very well known were applied: ELECTRE Iv, PROMETHEE I and PROMETHEE II. In the case of VDA UniComBOS was used. The results obtained with different methods were not identical, nevertheless it was possible to identify variant worth recommendation, i.e. variant 2 a , which was always on one of two first places in rankings, regardless of the method that was used. On the other hand, variant 5 a was found to be the worst solution - its weakness was confirmed by all methods. The analysis conducted in the article proved that both described approaches can be used for solving the decision-making problems connected with project management. Although both of them have some disadvantages, as for example necessity to interact with decision-maker in order to determine values of parameters in the case of outranking methods and time-consuming as well as tiring comparisons in the case of VDA, they can improve the decision-making processes and help project managers to make more reasonable decisions. As a matter of fact, because of the differences between them, they can complement each other. Therefore it would be practical and beneficial to employ them simultaneously in all cases when it is merely possible and feasible.
A new methodology for project portfolio scheduling problem has been presented in this paper. This methodology delivers information about project portfolio schedule, which is important for project portfolio managers. The methodology consists of three steps: multiple-criteria mathematical model building, finding non-dominated solutions and choosing one solution from the Pareto set as the final solution. In the first step a multiple-criteria mathematical model for project portfolio scheduling problem is built. Three criteria are considered in the model: the penalty for projects delays minimization, the penalty for resources overusage minimization and NPV maximization. Disadvantage of proposed mathematical model is a big amount of variables, which is J×T×P. In cases when we will have larger projects or larger planning horizon the number of variables will be huge. That is why activities aggregation was proposed. It reduces a number of variables in given model. It also delivers a general information about project portfolio schedule, which is more important for project portfolio managers. In the second step a set of non-dominated solutions is identified by using an elitist evolutionary algorithm. As research shows using an external set with the best solutions in each generation increases an algorithm efficiency. In the third step the LBS procedure is used to identify the final solution. The LBS procedure proposes is a way of learning-oriented interactive search for the best compromise solution for the decision maker. This procedure makes the comparison of non-dominated solution in the decision phase relatively easy. So this step will not burden the decision maker too much. For the future work, the procedure presented in this paper will be applied to the problem described in the section two, and given results will be compared with the current situation in the company.
Theorems about the rational decision making play very important role in the decision theory. According to these theorems people make their decisions by using the rule about maximum benefits. However in the literature we can find conclusions from research and experiments which indicate that when people are making decisions, they are very often breaking that rule about maximum profits. According to that research a few paradoxes of rationality were formulated. In this article experiments concerning the Allais paradoxes are analyzed. The incompatibility between paradox and the expected utility theory were discussed. Also the certainty effect and the common consequence effect were analyzed.
W pracy tej analizowane są własności metody rozwiązywania wielokryterialnych problemów decyzyjnych, zwanej metodą nietradycyjnych kryteriów inwestycji kapitałowych (Nontraditional Capital Investment Criteria, NCIC), w porównaniu z metodą analitycznego procesu hierarchii (Analytic Hierarchy Process, AHP). Przedstawiony jest tez przykład pokazujący wykorzystanie w praktyce metody NCIC. (fragment tekstu)
The post-modern society has moved to an era of information society. The aim of this article is to analyze the impact of the information society concept on the contemporary society in Europe and in Global context. We would like to focus on selected benefits and threats the new information technologies mean to lives of contemporary people and reflect on what might be some consequences of the global use of information society in the coming years.
Based on a literature analysis of the applicability of econometric and analytical models in the forecasting of social responses it was concluded that a dominating role is played by conditions and rules deriving from statistical physics. These models examine the straight behaviour and reactions of group members in a specific situation. There are no models where the behaviour of participants is related to phenomena occurring in their environment (closer and further) and dynamically changing states of this environment (in particular the information environment). A model for the study of the web information impact on social responses has been proposed to complement the identified research gap. The model has been evaluated on the basis of investment decisions made at the Warsaw Stock Exchange. The conducted analyzes show the usefulness of the model and the possibility of its further development in the wider context of social applications.
This study incorporated expert knowledge into the classical quadratic programming approach, i.e., Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT), through fuzzy set theory; in obtaining portfolio return optimization involving direct real estate investment. Two fuzzy mathematical programming models were uniquely specified and estimated in this study, namely, Zimmer-mann's (2001) fuzzy tactical asset allocation (FTAA) flexible programming model and Ramik and Rimanek's (1985) FTAA robust programming model. These approaches try to overcome the drawbacks of traditional asset allocation models by including expert adjustment in the presence of imprecise information. The findings suggest that the fuzzy tactical asset allocation (FTAA Flexible Model), with the inclusion of expert judgments which contain information usually not found in historical data, is able to produce a portfolio just as efficient as traditional asset allocation models while minimizing the potential issues due to imprecision and vagueness of information. Meanwhile, the FTAA Robust Model proffers a more evenly-distributed, yet with higher risks and lower returns, portfolio. Aside from the lack of emphasis on portfolio risks minimization, one reason attributed to such anomaly is the low level of returns of high-risk stocks that are not selected by MPT and FTAA Flexible Models. It results in a unique situation where portfolio diversification does not necessarily guarantee an efficient investment decision.
LT
Šis tyrimas itraukia ekspertines žinias i klasikine kvadratinio programavimo metodika pavyzdžiui, moderniaja portfelio valdymo teorija per neapibrEeDžtuju aibiu teorija siekiant optimizuoti portfelio graža apimant tiesiogines nekilnojamojo turto investicijas. Šiame tyrime išsamiai aprašomi ir ivertinami du neapibrėžtojo matematinio programavimo modeliai. Tai Zimmermann (2001) neapibrėžtasis aktyvu paskirstymo lankstusis programavimo modelis ir Ramik bei Rimanek (1985) neapibrėžtasis aktyvu paskirstymo robustinis programavimo modelis. Juos taikant bandoma pašalinti tradiciniu aktyvu paskirstymo metodu trūkumus itraukiant ekspertu siūlomus pakeitimus nesant tikslios informacijos. Nustatyta, kad neapibrėžtasis aktyvu paskirstymas (neapibrěžtasis aktyvu paskirstymo lankstusis programavimo modelis) kartu su ekspertu vertinimais, paprastai apimančiais informacija kurios negalima rasti tarp istoriniu duomenu, leidžia sudaryti toki pati efektyvu portfeli, kaip ir tradiciniai aktyvu paskirstymo modeliai, tačiau minimizuojant potencialius nesutarimus, kuriu atsiranda dėl netikslios ir neapibrěžtos informacijos. Neapibrėžtasis aktyvu paskirstymo robustinis programavimo modelis siūlo tolygiau paskirstyta tačiau rizikingesni ir ne toki pelninga portfeli. Be portfelio rizikos minimizavimo trūkumo, dar viena priežastis, priskiriama prie šios anomalijos, yra maža didelės rizikos akciju, graža, kuri nēra pasirenkama moderniojoje portfelio valdymo teorijoje ir neapibrēžtuju aktyvu paskirstymo lanksčiuosiuose programavimo modeliuose. Kaip rezultatas gaunama unikali situacija, kai portfelio diversifikavimas nebūtinai garantuoja efektyvu investavimo sprendima.
The paper presents fundamental, selected opinions of the rationality issue in context of economic theory of utility. Main aspects of the rational behaviour generated by precursors of utilitarianism are shown. Also a fresh approach of behavioral economics is described, with its derogations from strict rules of conduct rational homo oeconomicus. In the article criticism relating to the presentation of a model of economic phenomena can be found.
In this paper analytic hierarchy process (AHP), a well-known approach for handling multi-criteria decision making problems, is discussed. It is based on pairwise comparisons. The methods for deriving the priority vectors from comparison matrices are examined. The existing methods for aggregating the individual comparison matrices into a group comparison matrix are revised. A method for aggregation, called WGMDEA, is proposed for application in the case study. Because exact (crisp) values cannot always express the subjectivity and the lack of information on the part of a decision maker, the interval judgments are more suitable in such cases. Two main methodological problems emerge when dealing with interval comparison matrices in group AHP: a) to aggregate individual crisp preferences into the joint interval matrix, b) to calculate the weights from the joint interval comparison matrix. In the paper we first discuss the already proposed approaches to the aggregation of individual matrices, and the derivation of weights from interval comparison matrices, pertained to AHP group decision making methodology. Then, a new method, ADEXTREME, for generating the interval group judgments from individual judgments is proposed. A numerical example based on Rural Development Program of the Republic of Slovenia in 2007-2013 is presented to illustrate the new methodology for deriving the weights from interval comparison matrices. The results obtained by WGMDEA, MEDINT and ADEXTREME methods are compared.
Problem gospodarowania wodą ma kluczowe znaczenie dla funkcjonowania społeczności i biznesu. Możliwości usprawnienia zaopatrzenia w wodę poprzez poprawę funkcjonowania przedsiębiorstw wodociągowych można poszukiwać, konstruując zintegrowane systemy informatyczne dla tych firm. Elementami tych systemów powinny być odpowiednio dobrane metody i modele podejmowania decyzji. Umożliwiają one dokonywanie racjonalnych wyborów odnośnie do wyboru miejsc pozyskiwania i produkcji wody, budowania i usprawniania struktury sieci wodociągowych, poprawy funkcjonowania przedsiębiorstw zaopatrzenia w wodę oraz lepszego wykorzystania urządzeń magazynujących i uzdatniających wodę. Proponowany w artykule system SDSS (Spatial Decision Support System) z zaimplementowanymi metodami optymalizacyjnymi może spełnić oczekiwane wymagania pod warunkiem jego prawidłowej konstrukcji oraz zapewnienia mu zasilania informacyjnego z gminy i przedsiębiorstwa.
EN
The problem of water management has key meaning for communities and business. Improvements in waterworks can be conducted through creation of integrated IT system. Dedicated IT system should include a variety of suitably selected decision-making methods. These allow to find optimal or suboptimal solutions regarding choice of water intake and production places, construction and improvement of water supply network, rationalization of functioning of water supply companies, improvement of usage of installations for water treatment and storage. The proposed in the article SDSS (Spatial Decision Support System) system with implemented optimization methods can fulfil expected requirements through proper construction and providing information supply from commune and water supply company.
An important part of the innovation management is to select the best new product project from the preliminary large set of potential alternatives. This problem is broadly discussed in the extant literature. Although the qualitative approaches dominate in literature, there are few examples of more formal decision procedures based on multiple criteria analysis. This article brings an example of interactive procedure that can help decision making in the new product development. As to the authors knowledge, such approach has not been proposed so far to the problem of selecting new product. The interactive procedure gives to the DM an opportunity to actively participate in the whole process and observe its development. During the procedure, the DM can disclose his preferences and values of trade-offs. This kind of assessment of differences in importance of criteria is assumed as more reliable then the direct assessment of weights.
The Hurwicz rule and the Bayes rule are classical approaches applied in the decision making under uncertainty. This situation occurs when the decision maker may choose one of several alternatives and he or she is only able to assign to each of them an interval of potential payoffs or a set of possible profits. In both cases the answer obtained depends on the state of nature (scenario) which will happen, but in the first case the set of scenarios is infinite and in the second one - it is finite. The Hurwicz measure, with the aid of the coefficient of pessimism and the coefficient of optimism, enables to find the optimal pure strategy when the decision selected is performed only once. Meanwhile the Bayes criterion is designed to indicate the optimal pure or mixed strategy when the variant chosen is performed once or many times. In the first part of the article the author analyzes the Hurwicz rule and illustrates cases when the use of this criterion leads to quite unexpected results which seem to be contradictory with the logic and do not reflect the decision maker's preferences. In the second part a proposal of an approach for optimal pure strategy searching (by means of formulas considering both the coefficients of pessimism and optimism, as well as the whole set of payoffs) is presented. This procedure (H+B rule) combines elements of the Hurwicz criterion and the Bayes criterion, but is deprived of disadvantages typical of the Hurwicz rule. The rule suggested takes into consideration both extreme payoffs and intermediate payoffs, which enables to receive rational recommendations for a larger spectrum of decision problems. The H+B rule may be applied in the decision making process under uncertainty when the number of potential scenarios and the set of possible payoffs are finite, however a slight modification of the equations proposed enables to use this procedure in problems with continuous payoffs.
Rezultaty wielu przedsięwzięć rozwojowych realizowanych jako projekty mogą zależeć od zmiennych czynników środowiskowych. Wpływają one na wartość tegoż projektu poprzez wykorzystanie pojawiających się możliwości, co jest możliwe tyko w warunkach właściwego zarządzania. Owe możliwości są nazywane opcjami realnymi. Do ich wykorzystania jest konieczne oszacowanie przyszłych zmian wartości tych czynników. W kontekście zrównoważonego rozwoju są to czynniki nie tylko ekonomiczne, ale także społeczne oraz związane ze środowiskiem naturalnym. Na podstawie obserwacji danych historycznych możliwe jest tworzenie scenariuszy przyszłych zachowań tych czynników. Takie scenariusze mogą przybierać formę drzew dwumianowych. Niniejszy artykuł przedstawia ocenę parametrów drzew dwumianowych dokonaną na podstawie obserwacji historycznych czynników środowiskowych mogących mieć wpływ na projekty zrównoważonego rozwoju regionów.
EN
The results of a number of development projects may depend on the variable environmental factors. They may affect the value of that project, through the use of emerging opportunities, which is possible only in the conditions of proper management. These opportunities are called real options. To use them, it is necessary to estimate future changes in the value of these factors. In the context of sustainable development, the factors are not only economic but also social and related to environment. Based on the observation of historical data, it is possible to create scenario future behavior of these factors. Such scenarios may take the form of binomial trees. This paper presents the evaluation of the parameters of binomial trees made based on historical observations of environmental factors that may influence on the projects of sustainable development of regions.
The behavior of the risk averse decision-maker is prudent if the precautionary saving activities are taken to avoid risk. Prudence is defined as a particular type of the preference relation over uncertain choices. Our goal in this paper is to show the relationship between the Arrow-Pratt coefficient of the risk aversion and the measure of the intensity of prudence. The properties of the utility function expressing prudence behavior are presented and the particular class of utility functions with non monotonic absolute risk aversion coefficient is considered.
We present a new interactive procedure for multiobjective optimization problems (MOO), which involves robust ordinal regression in contraction of the preference cone in the objective space. The most preferred solution is achieved by means of a systematic dialogue with the decision maker (DM) during which (s)he species pairwise comparisons of some non-dominated solutions from a current sample. The origin of the cone is located at a reference point chosen by the DM. It is formed by all directions of isoquants of the achievement scalarizing functions compatible with the pairwise comparisons of non-dominated solutions provided by the DM. The compatibility is assured by robust ordinal regression, i.e. the DM's statements concerning strict or weak preference relations for pairs of compared solutions are represented by all compatible sets of weights of the achievement scalarizing function. In successive iterations, when new pairwise comparisons of solutions are provided, the cone is contracted and gradually focused on a subregion of the Pareto optimal set of greatest interest. The DM is allowed to change the reference point and the set of pairwise comparisons at any stage of the method. Such preference information does not need much cognitive e ort on the part of the DM. The phases of preference elicitation and cone contraction alternate until the DM nds at least one satisfactory solution, or there is no such solution for the current problem setting.
In this paper an impact of the party’s negotiation profile on the misperception of the preferential information provided to the negotiating parties is studied. In particular, the problems with determining an adequate and preferentially correct negotiation offer scoring system is analyzed, when the parties are supported in their decision analyses by means of the SAW technique. In the analyses we use the negotiation data from bilateral negotiation experiments conducted by means of the Inspire negotiation support system. To determine the negotiators’ profiles the Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument was used, which allows to describe their general negotiation approach using two dimensions of assertiveness and cooperativeness. The accuracy of scoring systems was defined as the extent to which the negotiator’s individual scoring system (agent’s system) is concordant to the preferential information provided by the negotiator’s superior (principal’s system) in the form of verbal and graphical descriptions, and measured by means of ordinal and cardinal accuracy indexes.
Who, what, when, where, why, in what way, by what means? - These are "seven golden questions" which a police officer should ask themselves before they make a decision. The subject matter of the paper is description of the decision-making by police superiors. The results of research aimed at confirming the specificity of decision making in police and defining police officers' behavior in difficult and stress-inducing situations of any kind which they regularly encounter while performing official duties. The goal of the study is also to indicate that making managerial decisions combines rational analysis aspects with intuition. Being on duty superiors pay attention to information concerning safety aspects. This kind of information is vital in order to take the actions staying in compliance with applicable law and not posing a threat to them, inferiors and society.
The article presents an application of chosen multi-criteria decision making method - the AHP method, under conditions of linear par tial information, in portfolio selection. Selecting a portfolio is a problem of choosing these quoted companies that give good profit. The problem of building a portfolio can be treated as a multi-criteria problem where some diagnostic features that characterize financial and economic condition of companies can be used as criteria. In the paper, the multi-criteria decision making method AHP was used under conditions of linear partial information (the criteria weights are not known precisely, only some linear cons traints on them are known). The approach enables to create a ranking of considered objec ts and may help to select the best listed companies to the portfolio.
This article presents a model of searching for some resource, e.g. a job, whose value depends on two quantitative traits. The decision maker observes offers in a random order and must accept precisely one offer. Recall of previously observed offers is not possible. It is assumed that the value of an offer is a linear function of these two traits, which come from a bivariate normal distribution. We consider the following four strategy sets: i) the decision on whether to accept an offer is based purely on the first trait, ii) any decision is only made after observing both traits, iii) after observing the first trait, the decision maker can either immediately accept, immediately reject or observe the second trait and then decide, iv) after observing the first trait, the decision maker can either immediately reject or observe the second trait and then decide. The goal of the decision maker is to maximize his expected reward, where the reward is equal to the value of the offer selected minus the search costs. The optimal strategy from each of these four sets is derived. An example is given.
W artykule opisano możliwości wspomagania pracy użytkownika systemu klasy ERP w wykonywaniu zadań, które obejmują przygotowanie analizy danych pobranych z systemu SAP Business One. Przedstawiono sposoby określające, jak użytkownicy systemów informatycznych mogą doskonalić wykonywanie codziennych zadań. Wykazano prawdziwość tezy, że prosumpcja oddziałuje na proces podejmowania decyzji i zwiększa zaangażowanie użytkownika w analizę danych biznesowych.
JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Turn it on to take full advantage of this site, then refresh the page.